2 ms·
It's not really well understood. Decoherence is an approximation it speaks of the appearance. The problem with QM isn't mathematic or experimental. It's philo
by ThomPete 16y ago
It's not really well understood.
Decoherence is an approximation it speaks of the appearance.
The problem with QM isn't mathematic or experimental. It's philosophical.
In other words it just doesn't make sense even though it's as proven as classical physics.
You got non-locality up against locality (or discreet)
Both are true. This is the paradox and no interpretation fully explains QM.
- Retric 16y agoIt's well understood in that we have a model which explains what happens to a high degree of accuracy. Unfortunately while people understand how to use the model it does not seem intuitive. IMO, that just means that while humanity understands it people don't. PS: I would argue that the same split occurs in several areas. I don't think any one person really understands a modern CPU, but get a large enough group of people together and we can still build them.
- ThomPete 16y agoI am not sure I understand what you mean with this: "that just means that while humanity understands it people don't."
- grhino 16y agoThis is what I think he means. Considered as a whole rather than individual persons, humanity understands how to apply quantum mechanics, in particular, to collapse the wave function. However, few or no individuals actually intuitively understand the subtle details of modern quantum mechanics. If you can take the perspective of humanity as an entity which can "understand" things, then humanity knows a lot more than any individual knows.
- ThomPete 16y agoThere are many things that humans know intuitively and have known for centuries. They just haven't known why something works a given way. It's the ability to explain it that makes you understand it.
- Retric 16y agoPlenty of people teach QM, but they don't have an intuitive understanding of it. Evolution has enabled us to have a solid grasp of what baseballs do, but things 1/1,000,000,000,000,000,000,00th of that volume don't behave like baseballs.
- ThomPete 16y agoYes they teach the math and the experiments like Bells theorem. They teach what we know about QM. But that is not the same as there is nothing more to understand, that all puzzles have been solved. There are how many different interpretations of QM? 10+ well known and however many not so known. None of them are able to explain everything without: 1. Introducing some kind of quantum weirdness 2. Asking for a leap of faith 3. Explains it in n dimensions but doesn't allow for predictions.
- lisper 16y agoNo, you are mistaken. The discrete is an approximation to the continuous for large systems, just as Newtonian mechanics as an approximation to the relativistic for slow speeds and low gravity. It is all perfectly well understood, and there are no contradictions or paradoxes. There is only a publishing industry that finds it profitable to promulgate the myth that there is something mysterious going on.
- ThomPete 16y agoIf you feel it's well understood what keeps you from getting a Nobel? Am I to read into what you are writing that you believe in the plasma theory?
- lisper 16y ago> If you feel it's well understood what keeps you from getting a Nobel? Because there is no Nobel prize for understanding things that other people have discovered. > Am I to read into what you are writing that you believe in the plasma theory? I have no idea what the plasma theory is.