8 ms·
This reminds me that SF's actual neighbor to the north, Marin County, is mostly real unbuilt wilderness. This is all such an epic waste.
by BurningFrog 8y ago
This reminds me that SF's actual neighbor to the north, Marin County, is mostly real unbuilt wilderness.
This is all such an epic waste.
- azinman2 8y agoYou have to balance short term housing with the desirability of the location in the first place. I would not call it epic waste, I’d call it a nice contrast to the density of the city and a place for those who don’t want density can go live.
- protonimitate 8y agoAgreed. Why clear-cut and destroy wilderness instead of building vertically? Expanding the metro region just increases commuting times and removes and recreational value the wilderness provides. Not sure why people would want suburban waste lands instead of denser metro areas.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mikeryan 8y agoThis is true, a better solution (for everyone) then high rises might be better access through (or around?) the city to the east and north bays. Getting into, or especially through SF from Marin is a nightmare.
- stcredzero 8y agohigh rises might be better access through (or around?) the city to the east and north bays How about having them in the east and north bay? How about large vessels operating as gated communities, with integral ferry docks? Getting into, or especially through SF from Marin is a nightmare. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17567916 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17567916
- tarr11 8y ago"Real unbuilt wilderness" has some value to many of us. [0] [1] [0] https://www.nps.gov/muwo/index.htm https://www.nps.gov/muwo/index.htm [1] https://www.parks.ca.gov/?page_id=471 https://www.parks.ca.gov/?page_id=471
- nerdponx 8y agoTo be fair, there is something to be said for increasing urban density while preserving unbuilt wilderness close at hand (and yes, you can still preserve "local character" in select historical neighborhoods via lottery).
- ISL 8y agoWilderness is the opposite of waste.
- butterfi 8y agoOh yes, lets turn one of the last Bay Area counties that isn't urban sprawl into another vast wasteland of concrete and strip malls. Redwoods are overrated. Wetlands are just swampy land that need an In-n-Out. Mt.Tam would be so much nicer if it had some restaurants and gift shops.
- docker_up 8y agoThat exact same argument can be made about building more high density buildings in SF. "Let's turn one of the most beautiful cities in the world into an urban jungle filled with high rises so that it blocks out the sun." At some point something has got to give. Building more apartment buildings and decreasing the amount of "open space" to accommodate more housing makes sense.
- throwaway76543 8y agoBuilding apartments in cities makes sense, both economically and environmentally. Building anything in the open space in Marin is nonsense and would create an enormous commute problem as well as harm the environment -- both directly and with secondary effects of increased commute emissions.
- butterfi 8y agoIn the past, I heard the story that BART was blocked in Marin by wealthy NIMBY's who didn't want to share, but just recently I learned this was BS. Turns out BART canceled the Marin expansion because: 1) GG Bridge couldn't take the extra weight of another deck; 2) Building to Marin would have make the whole BART project too expensive at the time, so Marin got cut. Interesting! (Thanks to Bay Curious)
- lemoncucumber 8y agoI’ve read that it was San Mateo county pulling out that made it economically unviable to include Marin (as well as disagreements between BART and the GG bridge district about the engineering viability of going across the bridge).
- CydeWeys 8y agoSuburban sprawl is one of the main problems that we are facing. Building more sprawl isn't a solution to anything, it just makes the problem worse, while also decimating precious wilderness areas in the bargain. How would people living north of the Golden Gate commute to their jobs in SF? The only option is driving across the bridge, which already has horrendous traffic during commuting hours. That doesn't work as a solution. Building denser housing in San Francisco itself, close enough to workplaces or transit that people don't need to drive to work, is the real solution.
- jrockway 8y agoWasn't a BART extension proposed and vetoed by NIMBYs? I think the deal was, if there was realistic transportation people would want to live in Marin County, and then existing residents wouldn't be able to have a mansion a 20 minute drive away from San Francisco (if they avoid peak commuting hours, or just live there and don't commute). It is a waste. People want to work in San Francisco and live nearby. The government should be concerned about making that possible... because whatever the environmental impact, it can't be worse than the 3 hour commutes in a single-occupant vehicle that people have today.
- kindatrue 8y ago>Wasn't a BART extension proposed and vetoed by NIMBYs? It was the 1960's... so I'd probably say "vetoed by Racists" Despite California's stereotyped liberal/progressive values, the 1960's also saw Prop 14 "allow property owners and landlords to turn away colored people" winning 65% support. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_14_(1964) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_14_(196...
- pessimizer 8y agoAll property owners in SF are retroactively NIMBYs trying to keep young wealthy white and asian programmers out. Even though until 1974 the National Association of Realtors' Article 5 implicitly made it a code of ethics violation to move black people into a white neighborhood, and HOAs were originally called White Homeowners' Associations and their only purpose was to legally insure that all home sales in the neighborhood were to whites.
- stcredzero 8y agoThis reminds me that SF's actual neighbor to the north, Marin County, is mostly real unbuilt wilderness. Imagining a Sci-fi scenario. Elon Musk has Tesla develop an autonomous hovercraft ferry, which only requires ramps into the water to be built to allow operations. Access to and from Marin becomes several times easier, causing its population and development to rapidly increase.
- maire 8y agoThere is a difference between urban sprawl and wilderness. Wilderness is good, urban sprawl is bad. We should focus on high density housing around transit hubs and then build more transit hubs. We should focus on livability of the high density housing. There was a measure on the ballot in the south bay where a major builder wanted to rezone an area for more housing. That part was good since it was not zoned for open space but rather industrial. But then they wanted to remove all ordinances for livability. That was wrong and the measure was correctly defeated. Part of the problem is with the planning department, part was with NIMBYs, but part is with the builders. There are only a few builders who are capable of high density housing and they want to play hard ball.
- BurningFrog 8y ago> We should focus on high density housing around transit hubs and then build more transit hubs I couldn't agree more! Why should those hubs only be inside, south and east of SF, but not north of it?
- ransom1538 8y agoI was looking at apartments in Marin. Me: "Man I wish BART went up here." Marin landlord: "Nope. We don't want those people here."
- romski 8y agoThat's just one person's opinion. The reality was it didn't make economic sense to extend BART to Marin with it's tiny (at the time, and likely still today) population.