3 ms·
My guess is the role of professional sales people in retail was always over stated. People like having a personal relationship when they can, but often that is
by taeric 8y ago
My guess is the role of professional sales people in retail was always over stated. People like having a personal relationship when they can, but often that is a major luxury and probably doesn't actually help in the product selection.
- emodendroket 8y agoIt may be so, but these people did exist and now mostly do not. It certainly does seem to be the case that most are unwilling to pay for this expertise (although I've found that, for instance, with sneakers, it makes a huge difference).
- taeric 8y agoAnd, oddly, with sneakers and similar, I've found it is majority snake oil. I've been ridiculously soured on consulting experts for any sort of consumer item. :(
- emodendroket 8y agoGoing to a Marathon Sports and wearing shoes their employees recommended after watching my walk has made my knees feel way better and I'm completely willing to pay substantially more for sneakers for it. But I can't speak to anyone else's experience.
- taeric 8y agoI'd be curious to know if they actually tailored their recommendation to you. It is entirely possible that you saw benefits just from getting attention and spending a bit more. Simply stated, I've seen studies showing that paying more does increase the effectiveness of things. Even if there is no difference in the thing. (Sadly, I have not followed up on those claims, so I don't know if that replicated.)
- emodendroket 8y agoI have gone back several times and seen different people and they shared the same observations about my gait and recommended the same kind of shoes, and what they told me seemed to be corroborated by things I read (though I would not have known what to look for before). More than one person told me that they noticed wearing the sneakers corrected my gait. Also my knees really hurt (as Abe Kobo writes in the Ark Sakura, the knees are the bane of all fat people) and now they rarely do. It is not a double-blind experiment but I am pretty convinced that they know what they are talking about and that it's not just a parlor trick. Now that I know what I'm looking for, I could go on Amazon and find the exact same shoes for way less, but I consider their expertise a service I'm willing to pay for despite higher prices and smaller selection.
- taeric 8y agoThe question I have is essentially if the shoes you are wearing are better for most everyone. Most shoes are bought for fashion, not any sort of fit. As such, if someone is complaining about knees or any other walking pain, it is not impossible that the same shoe would help. That make sense? It could be that you just finally got ergonomic shoes. Consider people that have RSI and similar pains move to ergonomic keyboards. It isn't that those would not be ergonomic keyboards for everyone. They would. Just not everyone has pains and so not everyone needs them. However, an astonishingly high number of people will suffer wrist pains and not do anything about it until someone recommends they get an ergonomic keyboard. With shoes, I grant there is something about knowing these exist. There could even be different kinds of ergonomic shoes. I'm just a little skeptical there. I'm guessing there are more marketed types of ergonomic shoes than there are actually beneficial types. (If that makes sense.)
- emodendroket 8y agoLooking up "pronation" would probably be enough to convince you the answer to your question is no. To stick with your RSI analogy, you're proposing that everyone with RSI could be cured by having a fixed desk with the monitor, chair, and keyboard tray at exactly the same height.