4 ms·
Inequality in itself causes unhappiness. Or jealousy, if you want to call it that.
by fulafel 8y ago
Inequality in itself causes unhappiness. Or jealousy, if you want to call it that.
- jahaja 8y ago"Serfdom in itself causes unhappiness. Or jealousy, if you want to call it that." Interestingly, it seems to me that the current iteration of the oppression business can somehow always dismiss calls for justice as envy/jealousy, but never the previous ones.
- fulafel 8y agoI favour income distribution and the nordic model, and even calling it envy should not be a dismissal, but a recognition of a basic human emotion that should be socially engineered against.
- jahaja 8y agoI didn't assume you agreed with the envy part. I do however find it absurd that envy is used in this context - since the word would never even be thought about in the serfdom case. Words do carry meanings after all. In this case we have the mortal sin of the individual instead of the righteous condemnation of societal injustice.
- ggm 8y agoI always used to mis-use Jealousy, when I meant Envy. you mean Envy. The lord God is a Jealous God. He's not envious. That snark aside (sorry) I actually agree with you. relativism is all here, the mass inequality fuels dissent in unhelpful ways and the marginal freedoms of Moar Moar is actually low: if they paid more tax, the increment on society would be huge, and the decrement to their disposable income unimportant. Envy!
- LyndsySimon 8y agoThe misuse of "jealousy" in place of "envy" bothers me as well, but I'm not sure it was misused in this case. I would assume that if income inequality inspires envy in those on the lower end of the economic scale, it would also inspire jealousy at the upper end.
- ggm 8y agoHmmm... you know? you may be right. I tend to read use of Jealous to mean "I want what you have" but in this context it could be the super rich saying "you can't have what I have" which is .. Jealously guarding their riches.
- LyndsySimon 8y ago> Hmmm... you know? you may be right. I'm sure this has happened once before, though the instance doesn't spring to mind right now. Does it also bother you as much as it does me when people misuse "fewer" and "less"? "Fewer" should be for discrete concepts ("fewer than twelve items"), while "less" is for measured continuously ("less water in this cup"). > I tend to read use of Jealous to mean "I want what you have" but in this context it could be the super rich saying "you can't have what I have" which is .. Jealously guarding their riches. I tend to think of jealousy and envy as two sides of the same coin - one tends to inspire the other. If someone doesn't suspect others of envying what they have, they have no reason for jealousy - why guard that which is not sought? Recognizing envy in another for things you posses is often (usually?) the origin of jealousy. On the other hand, when someone recognizes jealousy in another, it often directly inspires envy. How often do people pursue things that they never desired until they saw that others valued them? What is advertising if not an attempt to inspire envy in your audience? We even have a term for markets where this cycle feeds upon itself - "Veblen goods". The more they cost, the fewer can afford them and the more that desire them.
- JadeNB 8y ago> I always used to mis-use Jealousy, when I meant Envy. you mean Envy. The lord God is a Jealous God. He's not envious. Wait, my dictionary (the Apple dictionary) defines "jealousy, adj. 1. Feeling or showing envy of someone or their achievements and advantages." What's the difference?
- mmt 8y agoThe difference is exclusivity or deservedness (with jealousy being a superset of envy). A combination of exclusivity and deservedness could be jealousy regarding a "cheating" partner in a monogamous relationship. To describe that as merely envy would be confusing, at best.