3 ms·
This does not seem to be sound engineering to me. Just the sole fact that they have no payload faring tells me that they don't have a single man with aeronauti
by baybal2 8y ago
This does not seem to be sound engineering to me.
Just the sole fact that they have no payload faring tells me that they don't have a single man with aeronautic engineering background.
- Etheryte 8y agoMaybe I simply misunderstood what you meant, but doesn't the box with all the bubblewrap and whatnot cover that purpose? They're already lowering it to the ground, I don't think it would need much extra protection.
- jfoucher 8y agoI think what the parent is alluding to is that a box shape does not cut through the air very well, and that they should add a more aerodynamic shape to make it easier on the drone.
- mattlondon 8y agoFrom what I have seen, the "box" here is not a cube, but more of an aerodynamically-sound shape (at least to a layman's understanding of pointy-things-are-more-aerodynamic). Not sure how recent this photo is, but it gives a feel for what the box looks/looked like at some stage: https://www.simplebotics.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/alphabet_project_wing_hybrid_2.jpg https://www.simplebotics.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/alph... https://9to5google.files.wordpress.com/2017/06/project-wing-traffic-e1496853046991.jpeg?quality=82&strip=all&w=1600&h=800 https://9to5google.files.wordpress.com/2017/06/project-wing-... http://supreme2.ru/geek/uploads/2018/07/g2.jpg http://supreme2.ru/geek/uploads/2018/07/g2.jpg
- baybal2 8y ago>http://supreme2.ru/geek/uploads/2018/07/g2.jpg http://supreme2.ru/geek/uploads/2018/07/g2.jpg Well, this does look more or less reassuring. Still, even an aeronatics amateur will judge whatever they have there as an abomination. I just checked. That man is... an industrial designer, not an aeronautic engineer.
- azernik 8y agoThat single person is a mechanical engineer. Wing as a project, though, has designed their own aircraft, so I'm going to say, yes, they have aerospace people on staff.
- samatman 8y agoWhy would one want that design constraint? It should be possible to fit a package fairing when possible and get more efficiency. But surely it’s preferable to design for odd-shaped and cuboid packages, and take the efficiency hit? The result is a far more useful machine.
- Sir_Substance 8y agoYou could also pass this on to the box designers. Charge them pro-rata with high accuracy for watts used to deliver, and team up with a cardboard company that makes compatible aerodynamic boxes. Let the stores make the efficiency decision.
- maxerickson 8y agoThe sides of the hook are shaped differently (one is rounded, the other pointed), so when it fits into the belly of the drone, the aerodynamically shaped package is pointed in the right direction. Makes sense to me to shape the box, then you don't have to drag the fairing through the return leg.