3 ms·
Isn't Obama just arguing for a version of the broken windows fallacy?
by criddell 8y ago
Isn't Obama just arguing for a version of the broken windows fallacy?
- crpearce 8y agoIf many people currently rely on breaking and repairing windows for their livelihood, a “stop breaking windows” type law has real negative consequences, unfortunately.
- wu-ikkyu 8y agoOnly in the extremely short term and only for those who are participating in the racket. It would be a great net gain for society.
- phobosdeimos 8y agoThe US is a democracy. The people in the racket vote. Its why democracies are oil tankers that can only change course slowly.
- greeneggs 8y agoObama wasn't arguing for anything, he was just explaining the politics of why single payer would be difficult to get through Congress. (For better or worse, Obama was famously disconnected from writing "Obamacare" and left it to Congress.) As an explanation of the politics, Obama's quote—"That represents one million, two million, three million jobs"—is exactly right. Sen. Lieberman (Ind, Connecticut) killed the public option, allegedly because of the importance of the insurance industry to Connecticut.