3 ms·
A nice summary, but I think a little too casual in recommending 'flags'. The official guidelines mention flags for "spam and offtopic"; this FAQ says to flag wh
by gojomo 16y ago
A nice summary, but I think a little too casual in recommending 'flags'. The official guidelines mention flags for "spam and offtopic"; this FAQ says to flag when you "think it's not HN material", a looser standard.
How about on-topic but trivial, repetitive, frivolous, flimsily-argued, outside-the-mainstream, etc.? Best to ignore, rather than flag these -- a flag is not a downvote saying 'less attention', it's a judgment 'no attention; against-the-rules'. (It stings far more when your earnestly-offered submission is killed than when it simply never musters many votes.)
I've noticed more people using flags as simple downvotes, and some good submissions have been killed as a result.
- jacquesm 16y agoThat's true, let me think about that, that's a thing that will impact quite a few entries actually. If you want to re-word a specific entry in it's entirety I'd be grateful, this is a hard one to get right.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 16y agoFlags are a penalizing factor in the ranking algorithm, I'd not want to put too much info in the FAQ to help people game the system / gang up on others.