3 ms·
I have no idea why, as I write this, the parent is greying out. It's the only reasonable comment on the article as I write this. I know you're really not suppo
by jerf 8y ago
I have no idea why, as I write this, the parent is greying out. It's the only reasonable comment on the article as I write this.
I know you're really not supposed to tell people they need to read the article on HN, but the paper underlying the article may be the least understood primary source I've ever seen posted to Hacker News. (This beats out the previous record holder, monad tutorials based around an actively incorrect metaphor.) This is not just a standard reiteration of the Fermi Paradox with somebody's new numbers pulled out of the air. It is a legitimately interesting analysis of the problem as a whole.
Read the article and/or the underlying paper, carefully, before just reciting the Standard Cant Against the Fermi Paradox, OK? (And downvoting the only person giving a decent explanation of it.) The Standard Cant is encompassed and superseded by the paper in question, with mathematics.
- reordering 8y agoI know I’m not supposed to pile on, either, but... how on earth is your parent still at the bottom? If you accept this paper’s conclusions, all the rest of the discussion here is about science fiction. There’s nothing about the theory or evidence that demands either explanation or refutation. And the one person who actually lays that out is being downvoted for, what, being too explainy? This is bizarre.