6 ms·
SpaceX has been a phenomenal force in space flight, but their whole philosophy has been to move fast and break things. And consumers have gotten to watch crash
by legitster 8y ago
SpaceX has been a phenomenal force in space flight, but their whole philosophy has been to move fast and break things. And consumers have gotten to watch crash after crash and explosion after explosion.
Bezos is making the bet that the average person is to trust their luggage but not their life on SpaceX. If they take their time and get it right, there are huge second mover advantages here.
- ninkendo 8y agoDo you have a citation that shows that SpaceX has more incidents per launch than other craft?
- kadenshep 8y agohttps://www.forbes.com/sites/lorenthompson/2018/01/15/doubts-about-spacex-reliability-persist-as-astronaut-missions-approach/#2aa33ff63305 https://www.forbes.com/sites/lorenthompson/2018/01/15/doubts... I googled it for you. >"Zuma" satellite is the third payload sitting on a Falcon 9 that has been lost in four years. By way of comparison, United Launch Alliance, SpaceX's sole competitor in the military launch business, hasn't lost a single payload in 12 years and 124 missions. >two recent government reports raise questions bearing upon the reliability of SpaceX products and processes. The first is an evaluation of quality controls among launch-vehicle suppliers to the military space program. That report, prepared by the defense department's Inspector General and dated December 20, found 181 deviations from quality standards at contractor sites. Over a third were "major nonconformities," meaning deviations that might contribute to a failure in quality controls.
- rory096 8y agoZuma was not a SpaceX failure. This article is FUD by the COO of a think tank linked to the defense industry. https://twitter.com/lthompsonlex https://twitter.com/lthompsonlex http://www.lexingtoninstitute.org/boeing-meant-america-centennial-assessment/ http://www.lexingtoninstitute.org/boeing-meant-america-cente...
- kadenshep 8y agoOkay how does that negate the other payload losses that SpaceX has had, with only half the number of launches as its competitor? SpaceX has 61 launches according to this: http://www.spacex.com/missions http://www.spacex.com/missions You've totally missed the point. Haha, and then you edited your comment to attack the source. Honestly the person could have been North Korea's super extra special space dictator and it wouldn't change the reality that SpaceX has a higher incident rate than comparable companies. Which is what OP basically asked.
- rory096 8y agoULA is indeed remarkably reliable — that is its main advantage, given its high prices. However, ULA is only the sole competitor to SpaceX in military launch — for commercial and NASA launches several other alternatives exist. Let's take a more thorough review: • Proton-M: 9 failures and 2 partial failures in 102 launches. • Ariane 5: 2 failures and 3 partial failures in 98 launches • Antares: 1 failure in 8 launches (this is SpaceX's competitor in NASA resupply launches) • Pegasus (smallsats): 3 failures and 2 partial failures in 43 launches. Derivative Minotaur-C had 3 failures in 10 launches. • Falcon: 1 failure, 1 partial failure, and 1 non-launch payload loss (Amos-6) in 58 launches (59 campaigns). SpaceX's failure rate is in line with industry norms. While ULA has a perfect safety record since it was formed in 2006, its rockets do not (though they are still impressive). • Atlas V: 1 partial failure in 78 launches. • Delta IV: 1 partial failure in 36 launches. >two recent government reports raise questions bearing upon the reliability of SpaceX products and processes. The first is an evaluation of quality controls among launch-vehicle suppliers to the military space program. That report, prepared by the defense department's Inspector General and dated December 20, found 181 deviations from quality standards at contractor sites. Over a third were "major nonconformities," meaning deviations that might contribute to a failure in quality controls. Bizarrely, the author here attributes nonconformities at all three EELV contractors — including ULA and Aerojet Rocketdyne — to SpaceX. The actual breakdown: • ULA: 21 major, 43 minor • SpaceX : 33 major, 42 minor • Aerojet Rocketdyne: 14 major, 28 minor https://media.defense.gov/2017/Dec/29/2001862093/-1/-1/1/DODIG-2018-045.PDF https://media.defense.gov/2017/Dec/29/2001862093/-1/-1/1/DOD...
- atonse 8y agoErr really? This isn't some social network – you don't get to just "move fast and break things" with rockets, because people can die. Also someone has to foot a very, very large bill for you to break things. Sure, maybe they test things out with rockets they know are already going to crash. But that's as far as I'd go.
- samcat116 8y agoWe're still 20-40 years away from when the "average person" can afford a trip on either of these rockets. And SpaceX and Blue origin are very different companies right now. A lot remains to be seen.
- rory096 8y agoThis comment does not deserve to be downvoted so far. SpaceX's policy is absolutely to move fast and iterate constantly instead of relying on hardware 'legacy' and keeping designs static. This is a stark break from the way traditional space companies do things, and both sides have recognized that it has caused some friction with NASA as it adjusts to SpaceX's way of doing things. Dan Rasky's (excellent) oral history videos[0] of his time as NASA's liaison to SpaceX for technology transfer under the COTS program touches on this, as does SpaceX president Gwynne Shotwell's oral history.[1] Blue Origin's motto, on the other hand, is Gradatim Ferociter: Step by Step, Ferociously. They are known for moving slowly and surely. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SMLDAgDNOhk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SMLDAgDNOhk [1] https://www.jsc.nasa.gov/history/oral_histories/C3PO/ShotwellGE/ShotwellGE_1-15-13.htm https://www.jsc.nasa.gov/history/oral_histories/C3PO/Shotwel...
- kanox 8y ago> consumers have gotten to watch crash after crash and explosion after explosion. No, it definitely deserves to be downvoted.
- rory096 8y agoIt's a valid point. Even though we informed spaceflight observers know that these explosions were experimental (and would've happened anyway, more violently even, when boosters were expended), the average member of the public may not be familiar with the nuances of booster recovery. It's plausible that it could become a PR issue.
- pavs 8y agoPeople watching videos on Youtube are not SpaceX consumer/customer. Or am I missing something? Here is a full SpaceX manifest both past and future: https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceX/wiki/launches/manifest https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceX/wiki/launches/manifest As it stands right now, they are most likely the largest rocket company right now (or at least the top 2), they seem to be adding more order every other month. Not a sign of their customer base losing confidence in them.
- reaperducer 8y agoconsumers have gotten to watch crash after crash and explosion after explosion Just like the hundreds (thousands?) of pre-SpaceX test rocket launches from Greenwood Lake, New York to the modern rocket era.
- stetrain 8y ago> crash after crash and explosion after explosion. Are you maybe confusing launch failures with landing failures? As far as I know SpaceX has had two major failures since they started flying Falcon 9. CRS-7 (second stage failure during flight) and AMOS6 (second stage failure during static fire on the pad). They had another minor failure where they lost an engine but still delivered the primary payload to the ISS. I believe SpaceX has had more successful Falcon 9 launches after the AMOS6 failure than before it. So they've doubled their flight count without another failure. Someone else brought up ZUMA which has been reported to be a failure of the payload provider (Northrup Grumman)'s specialized payload adapter which failed to release the payload correctly. SpaceX has had a lot of videos of rockets crashing into barges and the ocean but those were experimental tests which weren't expected to succeed initially and which have no bearing on the success of the mission. They made those videos public even though there was no need to. Probably both for PR reasons and because it's cool to see the attempts and failures leading up to their landing success. Holding those crashes against SpaceX is like holding crash test videos against an auto manufacturer because "their cars keep crashing".
- rory096 8y ago>Are you maybe confusing launch failures with landing failures? I don't think they're confusing them, but rather they're worried that consumers might confuse them. SpaceX's videos of their landing experiments got a ton of space fans excited about them, but it very well may have created an association of SpaceX with explosions in the average layman's mind. Blue, meanwhile, while it hasn't penetrated the public consciousness yet, deliberately projects an image of conservatism and caution. (That said, it seems unlikely that someone so uninformed would be a potential customer.)
- mkirklions 8y ago>it seems unlikely that someone so uninformed would be a potential customer. I couldnt believe my programming friend bought into the Elon hype. Has 3k of stock and bought a tesla. Even smart people have weaknesses and overlook things. I remember being an Elon fan until I saw on front page reddit: "TESLA QUIETLY SOLAR PANELS PURTO RICO" And it turned out to be a reddit astroturfing/vote manip thread. And then I couldnt unsee, so many threads advertising his projects. Elon is a marketer.