4 ms·
This misses an element that's really worth mentioning to designers. Simplicity is good. Few games suck because they didn't have enough rules, so probably if you
by tialaramex 8y ago
This misses an element that's really worth mentioning to designers. Simplicity is good. Few games suck because they didn't have enough rules, so probably if your game sucks you shouldn't try to fix that by adding more rules.
In playtesting this means noticing - the players never seem to cause X to happen. Is that because X seemed cool to you but actually the rules for it are confusing and add nothing to the game? Rip them out. Cry about it if you like, hold a mini-funeral for feature X, but rip it out.
The temptation to have too many rules is exaggerated for video games, because whereas a human player won't put up with six binders of rules for a 20 minute board game, millions of lines of custom code isn't a blocker for a AAA video game title even if, again, the complexity actually makes the game worse.
Which doesn't mean your game needs to be Snap, or Pong, but it means that making the core shooting mechanic of your shooter feel a bit better is a superior use of your time to integrating a half-arsed RPG element everybody will ignore anyway; a few more weeks on fine-tuning the card text for your hybrid card plus dice game will go a lot further than adding two other sizes of card, a cloth playing area, paper money, plastic tokens, and a life-size plastic rat.
Unless the whole point is to get the maximum possible money for your Kickstarter, in that case go for it. Stretch goal of hand painted miniatures for each of the 640 possible playable characters? Why not.
- adamredwoods 8y agoI've commented a few times (on BGG) on games where too many rules can cause frustration or confusion. Are the rules limiting or are they allowing a new ability? Do the rules follow a path that makes sense to the game (heuristics)? The work behind (tabletop) game design is to create a meaningful product in the most elegant and interesting way. Streamlining gameplay is essential. Keep what is meaningful, throw out the rest, and iterate again. The most recent game I played that I feel violated this was Feudum. https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/163839/feudum https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/163839/feudum
- milesvp 8y agoThis was my biggest problem with the game Brass. It had too many rules to deal with game breaking moves. Time and time again, I'd see something that looked like a strong move only to realize I couldn't do it in what seemed like an arbitrary 'can't do X in round one'. It was clear to me in retrospec that the rule was because it prevented these strong moves, but it felt tacked on and contrived. Worse, is you have to keep a list of all the things you can't do in your head, and they're the type of rules that are likely to be missed, only to have someone salty over losing look at the rulebook, and say 'wait, you can't do that'.
- lacker 8y agoFew games suck because they didn't have enough rules. How can you tell when you look at a game that "not enough rules" was the problem? A lot of games suck. Maybe they wouldn't suck if they added a new rule that made it more interesting.