5 ms·

There's no correlation, it can be a trigger, like giving birth can be a trigger. Let's make breeding illegal?

1000units 8y ago
There is a correlation between people who develop serious mental illness and people who take LSD. The effect you are describing guarantees this (under very weak and sensible assumptions).
- codyb 8y ago
  https://www.erowid.org/chemicals/lsd/lsd_health.shtml https://www.erowid.org/chemicals/lsd/lsd_health.shtml It apparently can bring out already dormant mental illnesses but is not in any way associated with the formation of new mental illnesses. We all know LSD was literally available _at the pharmacy_ in the USA up until the mid 60s right? The entire nation didn't go insane... And you can bet your ass a pharmacy will at least ID people trying to buy it, you'll know exactly how much you're getting, and there could probably even be an information packet to go with it. Currently if you want it you have to risk persecution, have no idea what strength of dose you'll be receiving, and there's definitely no information packet unless you look it up yourself. At the end of the day criminalization is causing more harm than it's solving. People have issues with all sorts of things, alcohol is a lot more negative but totally legal. In general the proper tact is to ensure access to healthcare and opportunities in our society. Then those with dormant or non dormant mental illnesses are more likely to receive the attention they deserve. Access to opportunities means people get involved in their communities and projects and become passionate about something and are less likely to abuse drugs overall. Or you can spread hogwash like "LSD makes ya insane" which is not directly what you said but how people will read it.
  - gepi79 8y ago
    > It apparently can bring out already dormant mental illnesses but is not in any way associated with the formation of new mental illnesses. The victim does not know in advance. The victim does not care afterwards because the result is the same.
    - 1000units 8y ago
      And how is he so confident it doesn't "form new illnesses," whatever that might mean? Like I've mentioned upthread, I've known a number of people who have clearly suffered from having tried LSD. Some of them will admit it was the worst decision they've ever made. Others will deny it, strongly encourage you to try it, and if you press them for how it might help you exactly they cannot explain, but there is a glimmer of anxiety and recognition that it changed them deeply in ways they are not comfortable with. And they want you to join them. It's very chilling. It reminds me of how you'll see in some gay communities when someone contracts HIV they will compulsively spread it to as many people as possible.
      - Rescis 8y ago
        > It's very chilling. It reminds me of how you'll see in some gay communities when someone contracts HIV they will compulsively spread it to as many people as possible. Do you have a source for this? Your claim seems like a very broad and negative generalizatuon of an entire group of diverse people, who are often marginalized.
        1000units 8y ago
        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bugchasing#References https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bugchasing#References
    - codyb 8y ago
      Sure, and the victim of a car crash doesn't know this taxi ride is going to be the one that kills them. The victim of Pneumonia doesn't know they contracted it in that one supermarket. Lettuce sometimes carries ecoli bacteria and spreads outbreaks amongst tens or hundreds of people at once. Should we ban lettuce too? And, I dunno what people you hang out with, but most people I've met are pretty hesitant to just shove hard drugs into their bodies. It's not like everyone would be forced to eat LSD if it became legal tomorrow. And I know plenty of people who've had bad trips (and many many more that have not) and none of them have gone insane or become mentally ill afterwards. I mean, just look at a concert like Woodstock for instance. Half a million people in attendance, huge counter culture movement, and shit tons of LSD. Look at Burning Man, there are drug overdoses, but they don't appear to be caused by LSD as searches for LSD overdose yield exactly zero relevant results. I just think perhaps you've been told LSD is bad your whole life when, really, it's not that bad. Take it with care. Don't go dropping tabs when you haven't done your research. But the literal vast vast vast majority of people who take it are fine, and many report it being a positive life changing experience for them.
- Uberphallus 8y ago
  Not really, because if there's no LSD there will be another trigger. People are sane forever or eventually have breakdowns, very very few people live on the edge, that's why it's impossible to draw a correlation out of the data.
  - 1000units 8y ago
    Neither people nor LSD is as gentle as you think.
- ada1981 8y ago
  “New Studies Fail To Find Associations Between Psychedelic Drugs And Mental Health Problems“ http://www.iflscience.com/brain/new-studies-fail-find-associations-between-psychedelic-drugs-and-mental-health-problems/ http://www.iflscience.com/brain/new-studies-fail-find-associ...
  - 1000units 8y ago
    There's also a significant body of literature that does not fail to find such associations.
    - AstralStorm 8y ago
      If there is, then a good meta analysis should be possible or already done.
    - ada1981 8y ago
      Feel free to add citations, but the most recent findings seem to suggest no negative impacts. Psychedelics bring forth what needs to be looked at; if one doesn’t have an intention or support to do that, they may want to want until they do. The same could probably be said for falling in love or starting a company as well. In fact, my guess is that romantic relationships and entrepreneurship probably trigger “underlying mental issues” with at least as much frequency as psychedelics.
ryanmercer 8y ago
>Let's make breeding illegal? Well, it certainly would help the cost of food come down and start reducing greenhouse gas emissions...

There is a correlation between people who develop serious mental illness and people who take LSD. The effect you are describing guarantees this (under very weak and sensible assumptions).

codyb 8y ago
https://www.erowid.org/chemicals/lsd/lsd_health.shtml https://www.erowid.org/chemicals/lsd/lsd_health.shtml It apparently can bring out already dormant mental illnesses but is not in any way associated with the formation of new mental illnesses. We all know LSD was literally available _at the pharmacy_ in the USA up until the mid 60s right? The entire nation didn't go insane... And you can bet your ass a pharmacy will at least ID people trying to buy it, you'll know exactly how much you're getting, and there could probably even be an information packet to go with it. Currently if you want it you have to risk persecution, have no idea what strength of dose you'll be receiving, and there's definitely no information packet unless you look it up yourself. At the end of the day criminalization is causing more harm than it's solving. People have issues with all sorts of things, alcohol is a lot more negative but totally legal. In general the proper tact is to ensure access to healthcare and opportunities in our society. Then those with dormant or non dormant mental illnesses are more likely to receive the attention they deserve. Access to opportunities means people get involved in their communities and projects and become passionate about something and are less likely to abuse drugs overall. Or you can spread hogwash like "LSD makes ya insane" which is not directly what you said but how people will read it.
- gepi79 8y ago
  > It apparently can bring out already dormant mental illnesses but is not in any way associated with the formation of new mental illnesses. The victim does not know in advance. The victim does not care afterwards because the result is the same.
  - 1000units 8y ago
    And how is he so confident it doesn't "form new illnesses," whatever that might mean? Like I've mentioned upthread, I've known a number of people who have clearly suffered from having tried LSD. Some of them will admit it was the worst decision they've ever made. Others will deny it, strongly encourage you to try it, and if you press them for how it might help you exactly they cannot explain, but there is a glimmer of anxiety and recognition that it changed them deeply in ways they are not comfortable with. And they want you to join them. It's very chilling. It reminds me of how you'll see in some gay communities when someone contracts HIV they will compulsively spread it to as many people as possible.
    - Rescis 8y ago
      > It's very chilling. It reminds me of how you'll see in some gay communities when someone contracts HIV they will compulsively spread it to as many people as possible. Do you have a source for this? Your claim seems like a very broad and negative generalizatuon of an entire group of diverse people, who are often marginalized.
      - 1000units 8y ago
        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bugchasing#References https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bugchasing#References
  - codyb 8y ago
    Sure, and the victim of a car crash doesn't know this taxi ride is going to be the one that kills them. The victim of Pneumonia doesn't know they contracted it in that one supermarket. Lettuce sometimes carries ecoli bacteria and spreads outbreaks amongst tens or hundreds of people at once. Should we ban lettuce too? And, I dunno what people you hang out with, but most people I've met are pretty hesitant to just shove hard drugs into their bodies. It's not like everyone would be forced to eat LSD if it became legal tomorrow. And I know plenty of people who've had bad trips (and many many more that have not) and none of them have gone insane or become mentally ill afterwards. I mean, just look at a concert like Woodstock for instance. Half a million people in attendance, huge counter culture movement, and shit tons of LSD. Look at Burning Man, there are drug overdoses, but they don't appear to be caused by LSD as searches for LSD overdose yield exactly zero relevant results. I just think perhaps you've been told LSD is bad your whole life when, really, it's not that bad. Take it with care. Don't go dropping tabs when you haven't done your research. But the literal vast vast vast majority of people who take it are fine, and many report it being a positive life changing experience for them.
Uberphallus 8y ago
Not really, because if there's no LSD there will be another trigger. People are sane forever or eventually have breakdowns, very very few people live on the edge, that's why it's impossible to draw a correlation out of the data.
- 1000units 8y ago
  Neither people nor LSD is as gentle as you think.
ada1981 8y ago
“New Studies Fail To Find Associations Between Psychedelic Drugs And Mental Health Problems“ http://www.iflscience.com/brain/new-studies-fail-find-associations-between-psychedelic-drugs-and-mental-health-problems/ http://www.iflscience.com/brain/new-studies-fail-find-associ...
- 1000units 8y ago
  There's also a significant body of literature that does not fail to find such associations.
  - AstralStorm 8y ago
    If there is, then a good meta analysis should be possible or already done.
  - ada1981 8y ago
    Feel free to add citations, but the most recent findings seem to suggest no negative impacts. Psychedelics bring forth what needs to be looked at; if one doesn’t have an intention or support to do that, they may want to want until they do. The same could probably be said for falling in love or starting a company as well. In fact, my guess is that romantic relationships and entrepreneurship probably trigger “underlying mental issues” with at least as much frequency as psychedelics.

ryanmercer 8y ago

>Let's make breeding illegal? Well, it certainly would help the cost of food come down and start reducing greenhouse gas emissions...