2 ms·
I am surprised people don't virtualize the game and do their analysis at a level that the OS and game can't detect. Ultimately, these games trust that the hard
by jrockway 8y ago
I am surprised people don't virtualize the game and do their analysis at a level that the OS and game can't detect. Ultimately, these games trust that the hardware they're running on behaves according to specification. That is clearly an unwise assumption. Cheaters may not be taking this path today, but it gets easier and easier as time goes on, and it sounds like they're not prepared at all. (Some other comments mention that current games look for virtualization software installed on the same OS install that the game is running on and fails the integrity check if found. I can't imagine that stops anyone actually determined to cheat. I imagine it annoys people that test their Docker images on the same machine they play the game on, though.)
Even if virtualization is detectable, you can also take the computer entirely out of the loop. The state of the art for aimbots seems to be reading game memory and applying synthetic mouse movements at the OS level. That is quite a blunt instrument to apply and I'm sure that no game has a major problem with this kind of aimbot. A more elegant aimbot would look at the video of the game, look for targets, and provide the necessary mouse movements over USB. At best, the only countermeasure is to make enemies harder to see or to learn some heuristic in mouse movement that differentiates the bot from a human... but injecting randomness is straightforward and nobody needs a 100% accurate aimbot anyway. The pros destroy you with 30% accuracy.
Finally, it's unclear if there is even any advantage to be gained by cheating. If you want a higher rank in a competitive game, you can just pay someone to play on your account. From what I've read on Reddit... many of the people offering these services are apparently professional players. No anti-debugger hook is going to detect that.
It should be interesting to see how this advances. While games that rely solely on mechanics or information hiding are clearly doomed in the long run, it's probably good news for the rest of the software industry. What is your cloud provider really doing? Is your own software compromised? The tools used to cheat in games will be quite valuable in answering these questions and protecting your users from people that actually have something tangible to gain from these actions.