3 ms·
I worked in insurance for a company with a reputation for being unusually ethical, etc. While working in insurance, I heard that it was quite common for other i
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
I worked in insurance for a company with a reputation for being unusually ethical, etc. While working in insurance, I heard that it was quite common for other insurance companies to train their claims processors to look for a reason to deny, not a reason to pay. I was trained to look for a reason to pay, not a reason to deny and still sometimes found the bureaucratic process stomach-turning.
I generally am sympathetic to the conclusion of the author that the intent was to screw him out of his money. Having working in insurance, I have heard from reliable sources that this is a common tactic and attitude at most insurance companies and I believe that to be true.
Then, on top of that, issues for the insured are compounded by bureaucratic snafus etc. which I find abhorrent given that the industry generally runs on claims of being there for you when they are needed.
I have said previously that it boggles my mind that insurance is legal, especially health insurance. I think car insurance and house insurance and such make more sense, but health insurance strikes me as being like an ugly Running Man style game show called "You Bet Your Life" and I go through life shaking my head at the idea that the world is apparently okay with this state of things.
- Flenser 8y agoDo you think making insurance companies publish their payout:deny ratios would change their behaviour?
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI have no idea, but I wouldn't count on it. At the highly ethical, respectable company where I worked, this was going on: Periodically, some actuarial would have a cow about how some benefit was costing too much. The policy would get sent to the legal department for review. Legal would find some defensible creative new interpretation for the language of the benefit in question. They would announce that we has been paying this benefit "wrong" the entire time the policy existed. They would retrain the entire claims department to "pay the benefit correctly."
- zaarn 8y agoThe problem there is profit orientation and it's true for all insurances. Even car insurances do this even if you think they don't. They'll look for a reason to not pay you a dime even if it's on legally uneven feet. When an insurance is profit motivated, then maximizing profits is the first instincts. Maximizing profits happens by maximizing the deny:payout ratio. My car insurance did this by denying me reimbursement on a covered repair because I didn't go the the repair shop the insurance would have preferred (of which I was informed later and per law this doesn't matter anyway). On the other hand, my statutory insurance has covered any of my eye-care costs with zero questions asked or simple policies usually simply copied from the relevant laws (1 free pair of glasses per calendar year, up to 200€ IIRC, 10€/day for hospital stay beyond medical emergency, etc). The difference? Statutory insurance here is non-profit. Most insurances, even the private ones are non-profit. Very few insurances operate for profit at all. Other than the management overhead, the fees collected go straight into covering medical costs or are invested into fonds as a reserve.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoEven car insurances do this even if you think they don't. They'll look for a reason to not pay you a dime even if it's on legally uneven feet. No, I don't think car insurance is better about being willing to pay. I just think that it actually helps encourage driver responsibility on the road and it's less of an issue if you can't afford a car than if you can't afford medical care. I don't think the ACA actually insisting that all Americans have health insurance encourages anyone to eat right, exercise etc.
- moltar 8y agoWhich insurance company was that?