3 ms·
With enough mechanical aides, the game balance breaks. For example, SC2 has a very cheap unit called the roach. When burrowed, it can't attack, but regenerates
by vkou 8y ago
With enough mechanical aides, the game balance breaks.
For example, SC2 has a very cheap unit called the roach. When burrowed, it can't attack, but regenerates health incredibly quickly.
It's trivial to write a cheat that will, whenever one of your roaches starts taking damage, causes it to burrow, and whenever it stops taking damage, unburrow.
The unit is balanced around human control - no human can, with perfect accuracy, choreograph burrows and unburrows of individual roaches in a pack of ~60.
With such a cheat, roaches punch way above their weight, completely breaking the rock-paper-scissors balance of the game.
- maerF0x0 8y agoI do not deny that the game mechanics would vastly change. The strategy would shift away from "How can I micro these roaches" vs "How can i effectively attack burrowing/unburrowing roaches" to "How can i ensure I get roaches" vs "How can I frustrate/prevent my opponent from getting them in the first place"... As an aside, ANY change to a game is going to disrupt the equilibrium in some manner and I assume would require human intervention to re-establish a "fun" gameplay.
- vkou 8y ago> How can i ensure I get roaches Which is trivial for any skilled player, because they are an incredibly cheap, low-tech unit, and passive base defenses are currently very good at fending off very early aggression. > As an aside, ANY change to a game is going to disrupt the equilibrium in some manner Yes, and sometimes, the equilibrium settles on an incredibly shallow, uninteresting game-space. StarCraft is a game of a number of rock-paper-scissors cycles, all operating at the same time. Greedy expansion - versus rushing versus safe plays. Economy versus army versus tech. Roaches versus marauders versus zerglings. Sometimes, due to patch changes, poor balancing, or because player skill improved, the game ends up stuck in a quagmire, where the risk/reward ratio for many of these options is completely out of whack. The game stagnates, and becomes incredibly unfun to play, and to watch. Throwing a wrench into balance, by allowing auto-scripts, which have an incredibly uneven effect on the different units, mechanics, and races in the game is far more likely to push it into an unfun equilibrium, then a fun one.
- maerF0x0 8y agoYes, but keep in mind this idea and thread is not about SC2 specifically. It used SC2 as an example of the class of games that I personally believe I would find improved by removing the mechanical aspect of the game allowing me to focus on the fun part -- Making decisions and giving instructions patterns more than "micro"
- slavik81 8y ago> I do not deny that the game mechanics would vastly change. The strategy would shift away from "How can I micro these roaches"... It's kind of off-topic, but you will lose horribly if you actually try to win games on micro alone. People talk a lot about micro because it's flashy, but it's really just the icing on the cake. The pros can spend all their time showing off their icing skills because they all have solid macro underneath. When I played in WoL, you could make it into master league (top ~2% of players) by: ensuring you were never supply blocked, spending all your money, scouting your opponent, and building counters. If you were efficient, you could do everything you really needed to with an APM of ~50.
- invalidOrTaken 8y ago>With such a cheat, roaches punch way above their weight, completely breaking the rock-paper-scissors balance of the game. Against marines, sure. But against siege tanks/disruptors? Sirlin's spiel about there being more counters than people think (http://www.sirlin.net/ptw-book/introducingthe-scrub http://www.sirlin.net/ptw-book/introducingthe-scrub) seems applicable here.
- vkou 8y agoYes, they start punching way above their weight against tanks, too. Even moreso if you throw in an auto-scatter script. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IKVFZ28ybQs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IKVFZ28ybQs
- invalidOrTaken 8y agoWhat about tanks on high ground and out of reach? What if the roaches have to funnel through a walled choke guarded by some MMLib as well? That might seem contrived, but there is a player whose job is to contrive it! No, I don't think the next patch should include "improved" roach AI. But deep strategy games like Starcraft tend to have multiple levels on which to do battle, and you can often nullify an opponent's insurmountable advantage on one level by doing battle on another level. I honestly think that if super-roaches like we've been discussing were patched into the game, with no further changes made, winrates would stabilize around 50% in a few years (assuming everyone hadn't quit in disgust). Now, that might not be the game you'd want to play. I'll freely admit I wouldn't want to play it. But that's you and me---perhaps whoever's into chess would love it. And "This would no longer be fun for me," while perfectly legitimate, is a very different claim than "the game balance breaks."
- lodi 8y ago> ...deep strategy games like Starcraft tend to have multiple levels on which to do battle... That's exactly the point; the "other levels" are macro, micro, and multi-tasking--the "realtime" components of an RTS game. (I consider positioning and scouting a factor of micro and multi-tasking respectively.) Those are the facets of the game that let you take two equally matched strategies, execute slightly better than the opponent, and thereby eke out a gradually compounding advantage. If you remove those, the "deep strategy" of starcraft is basically just doing the one or two counterplays that you obviously need to do to survive. "He built too many early game marines so now I build banelings or I die." The strategic "if he does this, I'll do this, but then he'll do that" decision tree is very shallow in a game like brood war or sc2. > What about tanks on high ground and out of reach? What if the roaches have to funnel through a walled choke guarded by some MMLib as well? Then I'll be forced into one of a small handful of tictactoe-like responses: brood lords, vipers, doom drop on top of your army, or pull you apart with muta/nydus multi-taski... no wait. Just the first three options I guess.