5 ms·
> Argan trees grow exclusively in Southwestern Morocco, making them so rare that UNESCO has worked to conserve them by establishing a 2.5 million-hectare reserv
by stronglikedan 8y ago
> Argan trees grow exclusively in Southwestern Morocco, making them so rare that UNESCO has worked to conserve them by establishing a 2.5 million-hectare reserve.
I'm sure there's a reason they can't replicate the conditions and grow them elsewhere, but I'm surprised that doesn't seem to be an option with all of today's technology. This region seems particularly small.
- cm2012 8y agoNot that unusual. Almost all vanilla is grown in northern madigascar, etc.
- mc32 8y agoBut how many crops are like Vanilla --that is constrained to a limited geography-- but in the case of vanilla, also constrained by the intensive labor required. I mean, maybe Saffron? I think that there are exceptions such as these is proof that they are unusual.
- cm2012 8y agoTons! Even mushrooms are mostly grown in one county in the US https://modernfarmer.com/2014/05/welcome-mushroom-country-population-nearly-half-u-s-mushrooms/ https://modernfarmer.com/2014/05/welcome-mushroom-country-po...
- mc32 8y agoInteresting, yet I don't think they are hemmed in by geography but rather by happenstance. That's to say, the industry sprouted there and has had a positive feedback loop and bloomed, but it doesn't seem to me that it could not happen in Oregon, or some other place --though of course not every place in the US but several regions anyhow. I mean the GP was talking about crops which appeared to be restricted to small geographies due to special circumstances and could not be easily replicated elsewhere.
- danieltillett 8y agoWiki says the Argan tree also grows in Israel [0]. They would probably do quite well here in Australia. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argania https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argania
- efficax 8y agoI bet argania would grow fine in other regions, like southern california and mexico. It sounds like the restriction is the traditionally labor intensive mode of producing the oil. From wikipedia: "The most labor-intensive part of oil-extraction is removal of the soft pulp (used to feed animals) and the cracking by hand, between two stones, of the hard nut". Cashews and vanilla are similar.
- stronglikedan 8y agoThat seems to be the consensus, and I seem to agree. I think the article is incorrect by using the word "exclusively". I was going to verify it myself before posting here, but I think I learned more from HN'ers than I would have from my own research. Such as they do grow in other areas, and there are other crops that are seemingly constrained by geography but are, in fact, constrained by labor or something similar. Thanks all!