3 ms·
I don't disagree with you, but the obvious counter is that you are mixing causation and correlation. You would have to show that people are not investing becau
by slg 8y ago
I don't disagree with you, but the obvious counter is that you are mixing causation and correlation. You would have to show that people are not investing because they have no extra money and not that they are choosing to use their money now instead of investing. Realistically it is likely a combination of those two and therefore the comment that started this thread has a point that teaching people about investing can help motivate a shift in priorities which is better than nothing.
- kadenshep 8y ago>You would have to show that people are not investing because they have no extra money and not that they are choosing to use their money now instead of investing. We know they don't have enough money to invest. Average income + average cost of living < amount needed to safely invest. We've quite literally known about if for years on a national scale. He doesn't have to show anything.
- slg 8y agoI am not victim blaming, I am pointing out a way that the "broken system" has failed to educate people about the problem. You also can't just cite the average cost of living as if that it is a standard that has no waste in it. We need to do a better job of framing things like "if you switch to a worse phone plan and save $10 per month to invest, you will probably have something around $30,000 in 30 years while only investing $3,600.".
- kadenshep 8y agoI edited my comment to remove the statement "Stop blaming people for a system they didn't choose." I'm sorry you read it. It was unnecessary and you're right, you're not really victim blaming. I got frustrated at face value because increasing wages would do more to alleviate a lot of American's financial woe's -- now and later -- than (rightfully) helping to educate Americans about investing money. You're right, even small bouts of investment can net large gains in the future. I jumped the gun and took it as "if you just stopped being dumb with money everything would be better!" Wage increases are not only largely (historically) objectively justifiable, but wage increases would be more consistent and easier to "implement" than educating an entire populace in a better manner. There would also be the enormous task of changing purchasing habits. We know that even when people understand "doing X is bad for future results", that doesn't mean they'll make the more rational choice. Neither perspective is exclusive. We can increase wages and we should also invest in educating Americans about sound financial practices. But wage increases can happen now, would be immediately beneficial to everyone, while also making it easier to invest and take on the risks associated with investing.
- slg 8y agoI sincerely appreciate this reply. Not enough people are willing to do to what you just did. I agree with everything else you said here. More money is always going to be the quickest and simplest fix for this. I was simply pointing out that financial education should also be part of an ideal solution and that education alone is "better than nothing."
- peacetreefrog 8y agoI appreciate the spirit of this comment too. I do think though that where many well-intentioned people go wrong is that they think wages are just like a dial that "we" (or gov or whomever) can easily turn. I think this essay gets at a lot of these ideas very well: http://russroberts.info/article/the-reality-of-markets/ http://russroberts.info/article/the-reality-of-markets/
- s73v3r_ 8y ago"We need to do a better job of framing things like "if you switch to a worse phone plan and save $10 per month to invest, you will probably have something around $30,000 in 30 years while only investing $3,600."." Prove that is possible. Find an investment that will do that.
- bluGill 8y agoI can only find you that in hindsight - I can figure out the correct investments to have made over the last 30 years, but I can't tell you next years. For a reasonable return on investment you would be looking at 10k-15k final total depending on your luck.
- slg 8y agoThose were back of the napkin numbers. The S&P 500 has an average annual return around 10%. With a monthly investment of $10, it would take just over 32 years to get to $30,000. So I might have been a little too generous but the numbers are still realistic and the specific numbers were not really the point of the comment anyway.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoThe numbers were very much a part of the comment, and thus it is quite valid to guarantee you're still operating in reality when you make claims like that. Your 32 years to get $30,000 makes a lot of assumptions. One, that in 32 years $30k is going to be a significant amount of money, still. Second, that the person investing does not have an event in their life that would drain away any investments that they have, like an illness.
- noobermin 8y agoHas there ever been a real precedent for a society where a majority of them provide for themselves by investing in the stock market over living off of a wage? And I bet it is a combination of the two. Just I think it is probably 0.1% of because people don't do something they've generally never done and 99.9% that real wages haven't kept up with inflation.
- slg 8y agoNo one was suggesting that a majority of society lives purely off investment income, just that investing can provide benefits for working class people too.