3 ms·
The second and third questions are particularly mean in an average interview environment, whereas they are incredibly easy in a relaxed environment. It's reall
by Swizec 16y ago
The second and third questions are particularly mean in an average interview environment, whereas they are incredibly easy in a relaxed environment.
It's really really hard to think of stuff like that off the bat, sure in an hour long friendly chat I'll probably complain about many things in languages, thus answering your question. But if you straight ask my mind goes blank thinking "Huh ... well I could complain about a lot of stuff, but what is THE thing that bugs me ..." see, ordering by priority is very difficult to do. First one has to decide what their favourite language is (very difficult for programming polyglots) and then what the most annoying thing is.
That's hard.
Same goes for the third question. Well if I have a week to learn something, what on earth should I pick!? There's so many options, how many are really viable for a single week. And what would I like not to learn because I'm learning this. Again, prioritisation is hard here.
I think it all boils down to the fact that those two are BS questions.
- PaulJoslin 16y agoI agree with your point about the flow being completely different between a normal social setting and an on the spot interview question. It's amazing how your mind just goes BLANK as soon as the phone rings for the interview.
- brudgers 16y ago> "I think it all boils down to the fact that those two are BS questions." Useful if your goal is to hire people willing to put up with BS and looking to put their own BS skills to work within your organization. At a deeper level, the problem is that a person who actually hates features of their favorite language is likely to be miserable using the one their job requires, and a person who views languages as a tool for getting things done (rather than tribally) can't give an honest answer. A better version of the second question might be, "Are there any technical shortcomings within your favorite/current language?" Likewise many honest answers to the third question are entirely inappropriate within an interview, e.g. "I'd like to try a nudism for a week." A better version is quite possible. For example, "If you could try any other position within our organization for a week, what would it be?" is open ended, relevant to the context, and provides useful feedback about the candidate's career and growth objectives.
- Swizec 16y agoYep, exactly. I mean, if I had one week to learn _anything_ I'd probably pick sky diving or rally driving. I can learn about the stuff I do every day, well, every day. That one week should be special, something completely out of what I currently know how to do.
- 16s 16y agoIt's easy if you've coded enough to know. I hate the fact that in Python, to reverse a string, I have to do slicing: string[::-1] In Ruby, I can do string.reverse() so that makes me hate that about Python, well... that and a few other things, but otherwise I love it. I think he's looking for knowledge enough to know what you would do differently if you could change the language. Otherwise, you're not interviewing a qualified person.
- Swizec 16y agoI can tell you plenty of things I would do differently. But I probably couldn't think of them right off the bat. For example in python I'd change how function references are passed around. Especially in regards to passing them around to children processes.