6 ms·
You obviously shouldn't rely entirely on security through obscurity, but obfuscation can absolutely be an important component of defense in depth. Especially w
by monocasa 8y ago
You obviously shouldn't rely entirely on security through obscurity, but obfuscation can absolutely be an important component of defense in depth.
Especially when your attackers own the hardware.
- def_true_false 8y agoOr you could design the game mechanics so that client-side cheating offers little advantage... but that would probably require doing more than ripping off a popular mod of another game.
- B-Con 8y agoThat's literally impossible. The entire point of the game is to have client-side input and for that input to be generated by a human and not a computer. There's no way to move that to a server.
- wild_preference 8y agoI’m pretty sure their comment only really existed to dismiss LoL as a “copy of a popular mod”.
- def_true_false 8y agoI'm merely saying that they could have avoided some of the issues if they designed a new game from scratch.
- B-Con 8y agoThese problems are inherent to nature of being in the real-time PvP genre. And AFAIK LoL was designed from scratch, it's Dota that actually based on the code of the WoW mod. Not that it matters today, that code is long gone.
- def_true_false 8y agoI wasn't talking about the code. Btw, you are thinking of Aeon of Strife (Starcraft mod). World of Warcraft hasn't even been released back then.
- monocasa 8y agoHe's thinking of DotA, the Warcraft mod.
- Sohcahtoa82 8y ago> Or you could design the game mechanics so that client-side cheating offers little advantage Not possible in any sort of real-time game that involves reacting quickly to what your opponent does, or a game where user input precision is paramount. I mean, that idea basically eliminates all first-person shooters, where aimbots run rampant.
- def_true_false 8y ago> I mean, that idea basically eliminates all first-person shooters, where aimbots run rampant. Indeed, mechanics that reward mechanical skill are more susceptible to abuse. From the article: > For example, some common techniques we see include helping players dodge skillshots, zoom out farther than they normally could, or perform perfectly executed combos to smash their opponents’ faces. Scripting perfect combos can be mitigated by introducing more delay (i.e. backswing after using abilities/attacking), zooming out by giving the client less information about the game state. I can't think of anything that helps with dodging and skillshots.
- sthomas1618 8y agoAside from strategy/RTS games, I'm not sure if thats even possible? How does is ripping off a popular mod relevant here?
- monocasa 8y agoAnd even in strategy/RTS games, I can imagine a client side rendering hack that removes the fog of war for instance.
- sthomas1618 8y agoThat would assume the server is sharing the knowledge of other players through the fog of war.
- monocasa 8y agoYou'd probably need at least some so that you don't lag every time the fog changes.
- def_true_false 8y agoIncreasing the server tick rate would help with that. AFAIK Starcraft, Dota2 and LoL all use 30Hz. FPS games usually use higher tickrates. Some fighting games enforce a constant amount of (input and network) lag to make the connection quality unimportant (up to a point).
- monocasa 8y agoUnfortunately there's a lot of jitter in real world environments, so you can't really rely on that. : \
- sthomas1618 8y agoAgreed. Definitely not trying to say encryption is a poor strategy. But it does seem obfuscation is most of their anti-cheat techniques. But the larger point I was trying to make is that all these studios are very secret about anti-cheat but they all seem to be fighting the same battle. Makes me wonder if the industry would be better off with cross-studio collaboration and open-sourcing anti-cheat libraries (that won't be defeated by knowing the details).
- Thaxll 8y ago> open-sourcing anti-cheat libraries (that won't be defeated by knowing the details). This doesn't make any sense. Anti cheat rely on the fact that it's not known. There is no such a thing as open source in the anti cheat world. It's all very secret for a good reason.
- sthomas1618 8y agoI'd curious to know what strategies make secrecy a necessity. I come from a WebDev background and open-source libraries are almost always always secure and safer then your own (due to the sheer amount of developers and ingenuity working on one repo). Admittedly, game development is a different beast and has to deal with far more client-code so I'm admitting my ignorance here.
- monocasa 8y agoThe attackers are literally already able to run arbitrary code on the same machine, which is normally game over from a security perspective. Your secure webdev libraries also break under the same constraints.
- sthomas1618 8y ago> Your secure webdev libraries also break under the same constraints. No argument there. Different design goals. But I still stand by quality of engineering that open source allows.
- 8y ago