4 ms·
The major problem with that is there is no price transparency. If I go see a doctor, I have no idea if I will end up with a $40, $400, $4000, or $40,000 bill un
by ryandrake 8y ago
The major problem with that is there is no price transparency. If I go see a doctor, I have no idea if I will end up with a $40, $400, $4000, or $40,000 bill until the bill comes months later and I have to pay it.
I’m relying on insurance because going to the doctor is such a financially risky gamble.
- micaksica 8y ago> If I go see a doctor, I have no idea if I will end up with a $40, $400, $4000, or $40,000 bill until the bill comes months later and I have to pay it. NO IDEA. This is what's really strange about the American healthcare system. For everything else in America you can either get a price up front or an estimate of total costs up front. Why should going to the doctor be any different than going to a mechanic? Pay advertised flat rates for issue diagnosis, and get estimates for the problem. Yes, in cases of emergency you can't really shop around too much, but the majority of the time you're going to a doctor, you could at least call and get estimates of how much things will cost. It's not even possible to do this with most healthcare organizations. If you call your doctor's reception and ask "how much will it cost for this visit?" they'll tell you they don't do billing and they won't know until it's processed by insurance. Price transparency in the healthcare market - or at least some decent estimate of it - would be a great thing to see. American healthcare is ridiculously inefficient because it appears wholly designed to be byzantine.
- knuththetruth 8y agoOr we could just have universal healthcare with government-set price controls, just like Japan does. The ultimate in price transparency. Everyone is healthier, lives longer, and it’s far cheaper.
- lftl 8y agoI'd be fine with that, but I'm acutely aware living in the deep south that MANY people would not be happy with that. If we're talking about what's politically feasible within the US, "universal" healthcare is only really an option at the state level, or maybe with some federal maneuvering, as a multi-state regional coordination. It's simply not going to be accepted anywhere in the near-future on a national level. For the parts of the country that are rabidly anti-universal healthcare, a more free market solution would be a nice consolation prize.
- munk-a 8y agoI disagree, I think they'd be extremely happy with it... as long as they were prevented from seeing the words "socialized" in any context around the program until they'd seen the benefits. A large portion of the country working full time already has their employer offered health plans supplemented by Medicaid anyways.
- knuththetruth 8y agoThere’s already tons of people on Medicare and Medicaid in red states and there hasn’t been an armed insurrection. I think that working class people in these regions wouldn’t be adverse to Medicare being expanded to include them. I’m sure the Republican Party base of upper middle income and wealthy whites would be, but again, not so much everyone else there. It’s a matter of how and what constituencies you recruit and activate.
- ryandrake 8y ago> I think that working class people in these regions wouldn’t be adverse to the program being expanded to include them It’s so strange, the people who would most benefit from universal healthcare (and those that currently do, like Medicare beneficiaries) tend to be the strongest objectors to it, citing hard-to-understand ideological reasons.
- chimeracoder 8y ago> It’s so strange, the people who would most benefit from universal healthcare (and those that currently do, like Medicare beneficiaries) tend to be the strongest objectors to it, citing hard-to-understand ideological reasons. It's not so strange if you allow yourself to question the assumption that they'd benefit from it in the first place. Medicare is a great example. Patients can opt to receive their Medicare inpatient and outpatient coverage through a private plan instead of through the government-managed plan. Since this program was introduced, it's gained popularity rapidly, over a third of Medicare beneficiaries receive their benefits from private plans. Many private plans are the same price as Medicare or cheaper. From the data, the private plans beat government-managed plans on the three major metrics: medical outcomes, cost, and patient satisfaction. On the last one, the difference isn't even close: the worst of the major private plans (by patient satisfaction scores) still manages higher scores than Original Medicare does. People who haven't ever dealt with Medicare themselves directly (which includes most HN commenters) find this hard to understand, but it really isn't: dealing with Medicare is awful. I could give you my personal anecdotes, but they'd overfill the comment length on HN, and again, at the end of the day, the numbers speak for themselves. Medicare beneficiaries themselves are turning to private plans to replace their government-managed plans, so it's really not surprising if they're not the biggest advocates of expanding government-managed plans.
- rogerbinns 8y ago> This is what's really strange about the American healthcare system ... It gets worse. Each entity in the system applies their own rules. eg a friend had an eye exam at the doctors and they took 11 months to bill[0]. The doctor group pointed out their small print says they have 12 months to bill. The insurance company had a shorter time frame and refused to pay. But it was a scam - the doctor had changed the diagnosis code to get more money, and the insurer would have refused to pay so they kept more money. My friend lost. It is very easy to see which proposals will "fix" things. Look at which groups make less money due to the fixes (doctors, insurers, medical groups, equipment makers, drug companies etc). It is extremely rare for that to be shown, and all those groups will fight to keep what is "theirs". > American healthcare is ridiculously inefficient because it appears wholly designed to be byzantine. I like the word confusopoly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confusopoly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confusopoly Confusopoly is an economic and marketing term referring to a purposeful act by a seller or group of sellers to confuse the buyer in order to ease the sale [0] those fortunate enough not to deal with USA healthcare are probably wondering how this could happen. The answer is that any visit now results in a blizzard of electronic and paper communication, including satisfaction surveys, "courtesy" statements with many dollar numbers all over them that don't add up, stuff telling you legal information, and more saying one party has done stuff (eg billed or paid) on your behalf but you are still liable if it doesn't all complete, co pays, deductibles, random others because of in and out network nonsense etc. And this is a superficial description - how would anyone know?
- lftl 8y agoTrue, and the pricing issue goes even deeper. In my experience in shopping around between doctors while being in an exclusionary waiting period the doctors themselves often have no idea what anything costs. That's why I think banning non-catastrophic insurance would be helpful. I'm confident if insurance companies were kicked out of routine healthcare you'd see a very quick shift to price transparency. There's one doctor here in town that mostly caters to undocumented immigrants and he has a price board in his waiting room for cash price of most of the common services. BCBS (which is 90+% of the insurance market in my state) actively prevents other doctors from doing this. He can only do it because most of his patients don't have insurance.
- mixmastamyk 8y ago> There's one doctor here… We visit the clinicas here in L.A. as well, paid $130 for X-rays recently. Reminds me of trips abroad. That's all I want from health care, simple and transparent.
- ta1234567890 8y ago> If I go see a doctor, I have no idea if I will end up with a $40, $400, $4000, or $40,000 bill until the bill comes months later and I have to pay it. NO IDEA. Totally right. Which means in practice insurance is covering the risk of pricing rather than the risk of you having health issues.
- supertrope 8y agoIt’s a total racket. The worst part is that they’ve managed to tilt the playing field in their favor for even routine fees. Cash prices are higher than “pre-negotiated” reimbursements, unless you cry poverty and a billing clerk cuts you a discount after examining your tax return and assets as an alternative to collections. So you have to buy insurance which is an act that reinforces the hidden inflated prices model. Average people only have one rational response to random prices: don’t go to the doctor voluntarily. But this can cost them their health in some cases.
- felix_nagaand 8y agoTheir health? You mean their life. People actually die without health care. American health care is murdering Americans for profit.
- erikpukinskis 8y agoIsn’t Amazon currently working on fixing this? I recall seeing an article that Bezos was going to take on vertically integrated healthcare for his workers. And given Amazon’s history, the next step would be productizing that as a service for all comers with transparent a la carte pricing.