4 ms·
>You just made the same mistake you're criticizing Yes. Even if you take it into account, the vast majority of customers will see data loss, assuming random
by londons_explore 8y ago
>You just made the same mistake you're criticizing
Yes. Even if you take it into account, the vast majority of customers will see data loss, assuming random (but not even) shard distribution.
I rounded and approximated to avoid explaining too many probability rules... As you can see, it gives the same result at the end.
- ChrisLomont 8y ago>it gives the same result at the end No, it doesn't. You picked 3% of all drives failing out of the blue. Your next estimate was an order of magnitude too high. Your last assumption of p^# drives is not reasonable. The proof is in reality. Backblaze has run over a decade, with all sorts of hardware failures, server configs, running many drive models through their lifetime, across manufacturers, across technologies, across multiple datacenters, and had not seen the level of failures you claim they will. So I suspect their method of estimating is more accurate than yours. So far it matches reality much better.