5 ms·
The REPL for Hardware
- jasode 8y agoFor some interesting examples of what can be done with the Formlabs 3D printer, Ben Krasnow has a recent video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Z8uPHL52Q0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Z8uPHL52Q0
- huntie 8y agoThat's really impressive. I'm always amazed at what people are able to do with 3d printers. The other day I read someone used his 3d printer as a plotter, and was working on getting it to write letters.
- blacksmith_tb 8y agoWith stepper motors on 3 axes, most FDM printers are really overkill for 2D plotting. But it might be tricky to get a nice drawing, the standard slicer software that turns a design into g-code makes all kinds of interesting-looking choices for efficiency's sake. Evil Mad Scientist Labs make a nice robot for painting with watercolors[1], and the patterns the slicer it uses picks are odd to my eye, if sometimes fun. [1] https://watercolorbot.com/ https://watercolorbot.com/
- lispm 8y agoJust because something happens when you enter a command, this does not make a REPL. The original idea of a REPL was that one reads Lisp code as data, evaluates it and returns the result as Lisp data, which gets printed as such and stored as a side effect.
- na85 8y agoAgreed. A true hardware REPL would be incredibly wasteful, and you'd be throwing even more plastic waste away that would eventually end up in the oceans killing wildlife.
- lispm 8y agoIt would mean that the hardware material could be read and executed.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jononor 8y agoOne can engrave QR codes with a lasercutter. I've used them to provide a link to where to download the source files, for making more or to integrated the design with other objects based on the CAD sources. This was primarily to be read by humans, but one can imagine the same structure readable by machines.
- tzs 8y agoThe hardware REPL needs another feature that most software REPLs have: garbage collection.
- delbel 8y agoWait, hold on. Any G-code interface, like Mach3 or a serial terminal to GRBL is a "REPL". The only thing it doesn't have is loops -- which the industrial standard is to open notepad or vi, and cut and paste your "loop" into the terminal. I use this to face off material in my milling machine or manually move the spindle to "home" to remove the part. So far, I have not killed any birds, fish or whales yet.
- cup-of-tea 8y agoAs someone who has learnt and loves Lisp it's really confusing to me that REPL has come to mean simply command interface. This is the REPL: (loop (print (eval (read))))
- nixpulvis 8y agoThe key for me is that a REPL reads, then evaluates (generally involving printing), then starts over (looping). Bash for example fits this criteria. I'm as much of a fan of lisp as anyone, but it doesn't need to be literally printing the result of `eval` to be a REPL in my eyes.
- lispm 8y agobash doesn't print the result of an evaluation, the commands print if the want it's more a PEL: Parse Execute Loop
- earenndil 8y agoIn that case, most lisp 'repls' don't satisfy your definition either.
- lispm 8y agoMost Lisp REPLS print a result somewhere.
- cup-of-tea 8y agoThe P stands for print. A REPL prints by definition.
- earenndil 8y agoThen what is this? (defun add (a b) (+ a b))
- 8y ago
- regularfry 8y agoHeh, I thought this was going to be about JTAG.
- nixpulvis 8y agoSame, at first. And I'd have rather read something about openscad.
- nerpderp83 8y agoWhat is the Young's Modulus of an analogy?
- 3rdAccount 8y agoI always think Forth when I think of REPLs and hardware
- Animats 8y agoI’ve decided that 3D printing is the REPL for Hardware. That sounds so 2005. 3D printing is sometimes useful, but it's not magic. It's a prototyping process, far slower and far more expensive than high-volume methods of making things. Injection molding is so cheap. The former CEO of Autodesk, Carl Bass, thought 3D printing was going be a much bigger thing than it is. He thought every home would have one, because his daughter was printing dollhouse furniture. Didn't happen. He's gone now. What this VC seems to be doing is buying up marginally successful 3D printing companies. That's OK; some of them were just going too slow due to lack of money. It's probably a good time to pick up some of the overenthusiastic ones that were going zombie. Glowforge (formerly a Kickstarter) finally shipped, but they were too late. Now others have laser cutters in their $2500 price range. Laser engravers are now below $200 on Amazon. This might work out if tariffs prevent Chinese units from getting into the US. It's not a "3D Laser Printer", it's a 2 or 2.5D laser cutter for flat materials, like all the the other low-end machines. There are real 3D laser cutters.[1] Glowforge isn't one. Laser cutters are quite useful, but they're a tool, not magic. Also, despite what Glowforge says, they need a serious exhaust system. This fund also bought Formlabs. Formlabs has a nice stereolithography 3D printer. It doesn't really matter what they charge for the printer, because the resin cartridges are $149/liter. You want to change manufacturing, make injection molding dies as cheap and simple to make as printed circuit boards. Or a low-end laser cutter with enough power to cut light sheet metal. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1NsM0-9_n3Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1NsM0-9_n3Q
- contingencies 8y agoAgreed. We are a hardware company (invest in us, Brad, we're raising). I banned 3D printers from the office, and we just gave away the ones we had this week. Why? 1. Waste of engineer time fiddling about to get things to print right. 2. Often people have to alter settings or material to suit a part, then we tend to never know what settings were actually used therefore we cannot replicate the same part reliably unless we add additional documentation/burden to the process. 3. If the spec hasn't been sent out to a third party fabrication house then we aren't sure the spec is good. Using third party makes the spec de-facto validated and our interface to third parties standardized, thus supply chain becomes redundant. 4. We get free upgrades as industry iterates, with no capital down. It's like cloud services for hardware, except safer because it's transaction oriented with no technical debt or dependencies tying us to running instances. 5. If we need finishes, materials or processes that are expensive to acquire in a printer, instead of buying new gear or obsessing over integration we can just use a more expensive outsourced process. 6. A 3D file is possible to duplicate, view and diff remotely, a custom made physical part with unknown settings/material isn't. I've actually lobbied Github to enhance visual diff for 3D files, and they're considering it internally. Already we have used many processes: CNC machining, milling, laser cutting, sheet metal forming, thermoforming, 3D printing, injection molding, blow molding, various coatings/treatments, etc. Would hate to have to fork for all that hardware! Luckily, we don't. Also, we've just moved offices for the second time. It would cost many times more to move and we'd need many times more space if we had fabrication equipment in-house.