3 ms·
I've posted the math here before but if we assume that an asteroid hits the earth every 65 million years and wipes out the dominant life forms, then this fact a
by klodolph 8y ago
I've posted the math here before but if we assume that an asteroid hits the earth every 65 million years and wipes out the dominant life forms, then this fact alone puts your yearly durability at a maximum of ~8 nines.
The point about billing is better, though.
My other concern is that a software bug, operator error, or malicious operator deletes your data.
- GauntletWizard 8y agoThe event that wiped out the Dinosaurs was 65 million years ago, but the Mesozoic era lasted for ~200 million years. Your point stands, though.
- klodolph 8y agoThe question of how many data points to use is a subtle one, though. I can say that I picked one data point because I was lazy and doing back of the envelope math, which is reasonable because we can be somewhat assured that I didn't choose a number of data points that was convenient for the hypothesis. But if you're choosing two data points, my question is... why two? If you are choosing whether or not to reply based on whether or not the second data point fits with the first, then you're introducing selection bias. The chance that the second data point disagrees with the first by at least as much as the 200 My interval disagrees with the 1/65 My rate is equal to 1-(exp(-65/200)-exp(200/65)) = 0.32, which is not especially high.
- tjoff 8y agoThat's why no sane entity would use one earth. Use two and you can quickly recover.
- klodolph 8y agoOur goal is N+2, that way when one Earth is down for planned maintenance, you can endure unplanned loss of a second Earth. N, of course, is always 1.
- metalliqaz 8y agoRecovery isn't quick at all unless you have developed the Ansible tech tree.
- minitoar 8y agoIf you have two you have one, if you have one you have none.
- atYevP 8y agoWhy build one when you can have two at twice the price?
- toolslive 8y agoIsn't the expected life span of the company more limiting? Plenty of cloud storage companies go out of business (typically, they run out of money). You can apply Gott's law to this. It's pretty grim
- scentoni 8y agoI guess this is what you're referring to: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J._Richard_Gott#Copernicus_method_and_Doomsday_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J._Richard_Gott#Copernicus_met...
- toolslive 8y agoYes. [t/3, 3t] with 50% confidence [t/4, 4t] with 60% confidence [t/39, 39t] with 95% confidence
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> if we assume that an asteroid hits the earth every 65 million years and wipes out the dominant life forms, then this fact alone puts your yearly durability at a maximum of ~8 nines I don't think this is a useful definition of your yearly durability. If your data center is down for maintenance during a period in which it is guaranteed that nobody wants to access it, that doesn't reduce your availability at all -- if your only failure is an asteroid that kills all of your customers, it would be more accurate to say you have 100.000000% availability than 99.999999%.