11 ms·
The intolerable rise of perfectionism
- pygy_ 8y agoA perfectionist is someone with more exigence than talent. By deeming yourself a perfectionist, you openly state that you do not meet you own standards. Resolution lies on either end, depending on how possible/practical it is to improve a given skill.
- JadeNB 8y ago> A perfectionist is someone with more exigence than talent. My dictionary defines 'exigence' (which I had not encountered before) as "an urgent need or demand", and I find that hard to parse. Is either of the parses "… who is more demanding than talented" or (like "grasp exceeds reach") "… whose demands exceed his or her talent" correct? If not, would you mind clarifying?
- noisem4ker 8y agoI think you got it. A perfectionist's demands to self (as in standards they think should be reached) exceed what their talent can actually deliver.
- pygy_ 8y agoMy bad, "exigence" is a French word whose meaning isn't exactly identical in English. To be exigent means to have a high standard. The verb "exiger" means "to require". English adds an urgency dimension that doesn't exist in French. Many French words built on that template (direct latin root + -ent/-ence suffix) can be used as is in English, but it is not always the case.
- stochastic_monk 8y agoTo make this point relevant, are you more familiar with French and thereby translating an idea of yours in French to English with a not-quite-perfect cognate? Without such a connection, the reasoning for stating this is unclear to me. Could you clarify?
- pygy_ 8y agoI'm a native French speaker, fluently thinking in English. There's a vast pool of vocabulary that is common to both languages, from which I draw words indiscriminately (Latin roots and the same formula to derive verbs/nouns/adjectives, with minor variations for each langage (e.g. add "-ate" for verbs in Englsih and "-er" in French)). Some of these are so-called "false friends", with different meanings in both languages. I have a spidey sense that works most of the time in the English => French direction (e.g. "consistent"), less so in the other.
- stochastic_monk 8y agoThank you, I wasn’t quite sure. As a native English speaker who has learned French, I’ve often run into “faux amis”. Perhaps the most embarrassing was “préservatifs”, which I expected to mean preservatives but actually meant condoms.
- pygy_ 8y agoOoh, yes, that one must have been embarrassing indeed :-) "Préservatif" is such a weird euphemism.
- stochastic_monk 8y ago“Prophylactic” is no less bizarre.
- pygy_ 8y agoWow TIL. I have a medical background, so I'm familiar with the "preventive" meaning, but I wasn't aware of the "contraceptive" one.
- JadeNB 8y ago> “Prophylactic” is no less bizarre. Isn't it (less bizarre)? My dictionary gives the medical meaning of prophylactic as "intended to prevent disease"; using it to refer to contraception just requires a more generous conception of 'disease'. By contrast, if 'préservatif' in French were translated to 'preservative' in English, it would mean, again according to my dictionary, "a substance used to preserve … against decay." I find it a bit more of a stretch to generalise this to pregnancy. On the other hand, maybe it is just my English-speaker-ness showing through that I can think of pregnancy much more easily as a disease (it literally causes dis-ease …) than as decay.
- hinkley 8y agoI figured out what you meant. I suspect a lot of other Romance language students did too. Exiger seems like a 4th year sort of word though, and a lot of us unfortunately are only required to take 2 or 3 years, and German or Japanese are not uncommon.
- implements 8y ago> (which I had not encountered before) Me neither, in this context - though there's the US legal concept of "exigent circumstances" which allows police officers to enter property without a warrant if they believe a crime is in progress.
- JadeNB 8y ago> Me neither, in this context - though there's the US legal concept of "exigent circumstances" which allows police officers to enter property without a warrant if they believe a crime is in progress. Indeed, I had encountered 'exigency' and so had some idea of the general idea—just never 'exigence'.
- tjoff 8y agoI don't think I've met too many untalented perfectionist, I'm sure they exist though (feels like an unfortunate combo). I just feel talent is orthogonal to perfectionism.
- pygy_ 8y agoNot necessarily untalented, but not as talented as they wish they were. Edit: In other words, it's easier to have good taste than it is to be good at designing/producing something.
- s-shellfish 8y agoYou sound like you are projecting, honestly. Maybe you've been around perfectionists that worked against you rather than with you. The point of perfectionism is to be more talented. If you read too deeply into that and don't look at the whole picture, of course it's going to be annoying. But the root starts with a desire to be better because the feeling of stagnation is intolerable.
- pygy_ 8y ago> You sound like you are projecting, honestly. Spot on. > Maybe you've been around perfectionists that worked against you rather than with you. That would have been me :-) > The point of perfectionism is to be more talented. That's part of what I meant when I said "Resolution lies on either end, depending on how possible/practical it is to improve a given skill." Another way to resolve the tension is to accept to have lower standards and go on with your life. Both options can be valid, depending on the circumstances. Edit: Also sometimes, no one can humanly become as talented as one would like, yet going at it over and over until you're satisfied is the right thing to do.
- s-shellfish 8y ago> Another way to resolve the tension is to accept to have lower standards and go on with your life. For myself, long run, that is going to increase tension for me internally. I can't force myself to be satisfied with myself if I am not. I'd rather believe in a world that lacks absolute standards in perpetuity and have to consider myself perpetually adaptive than believe I've either succumbed to some group think ideology of 'relaxing' because it's comfortable for people who are fine with me being substandard (and then I get stuck with the problem of - is this because they are using me for their own comparison?), or been indoctrinated into stupid thinking that is fine with lowering my standards because it judges me based on a particular context that may not be indicative of an overall trend of my life absolutely. > "Resolution lies on either end, depending on how possible/practical it is to improve a given skill." At the end of the day pragmatism must be valued. Competition between people is useful but if it turns into a downward spiral of stepping on one another arbitrarily without reason, logic, without any ends tied to the means - then there is no united sense of progress from which every person inside a group can orient direction in thinking, and unifying action into something beautiful. I'm a software developer and computer scientist, so, all the spaces between coding (thinking, interacting) need to be filled in and can't always be explicitly stated. People have to make assumptions, it's easier to just decide - do you like where you are? Do you like the people around you? Can you see value in all of this? If you can't do that, that is when competition becomes destructive rather than productive. Being able to identify these things in real time, continual process of living life. I wish I could be weak sometimes just because it's easier, but my life hasn't allowed me to be. I make mistakes continuously and sometimes they are plain to see, not only to myself, but to everybody. The awareness of this - in perpetuity. This connects people to systems that are always attempting to correct behavior. So people who go over and over and over at it - it's the same thing. No judgment, being totally neutral is most simple. Functioning like a machine. It's easier to just call it aspergers or neurologically distinct. Can't know people's intentions and inferring them to be intentionally malicious can lead to disaster. The problem of wanting to avoid the truly worst things that could happen in life. Not just because bad things have happened, but because, hyper-awareness. We are always connected to things that say 'bad things happen to people' and not everything can be explained away. Talent, necessity, etc. Survival instinct. Calling it talent seems to be a diminutive, it directs the focus towards something narcissistic, vain - easy to prejudice against. Some things are born from necessity. Process of continual refinement, it's a compulsion because it says "I need to survive".
- foldr 8y agoI don't think that's true in general, because you can be a perfectionist about things that don't require any special talent to get right (just lots of time and effort). To take a trivial example, someone might be a perfectionist about ensuring that their shirts are perfectly ironed, but that has nothing (necessarily) to do with a lack of talent for ironing.
- unknowns 8y agoIt’s amazing to me how you pass off your opinions as fact. X Is Y. No hint of “I believe” or “my opinion is...” Let me tell you first hand. You have no clue what you are talking about and should spend an hour or so reading up on the topic. The most talented writers the world has ever seen have been crippled by perfectionism. Often going months without a Single word written. As you state the resolution is scientifically proven. Become more talented. I would love to see you say this to Harper lee or Truman capotes face.
- holografix 8y agoThis ^
- maxxxxx 8y agoSeems perfectionism is a good way to get burned out eventually. I don't think that level of intensity can be kept up long term.
- billysielu 8y agoI cna tpye 300 wrods pre minute
- tw1010 8y agoI tend to become much better at things a lot quicker if I just ingest a lot of the stuff (books, code, etc) and then spit out a mountain of it, instead of obsessing over making each and every thing I produce perfect. Perfect isn't even an unchanging state. The better you are, the higher your standards become.
- agumonkey 8y agoI guess our brain is tuned for experience. Even for trivial things, like tiny electromechanic setups, I can think hard and feel stuck, and often by just doing any thing, suddenly my mind sees a lot of new ideas. Probably a space search reduction.
- s-shellfish 8y agoPerfectionism is fine if you can concretely define measurable goals before you start working, and trust yourself to have a process of refinement that doesn't feel like a circular loop to you. This can be very validating for some people in a sense that it's autonomous - independent from validation via the economy and independent from validation via culture, both being dynamical systems and consequently difficult to predict shifts in preference. Establishing dependency primarily on anything besides your own standard is a shortcut to misery when someone just doesn't care enough about every little detail you lovingly put into something. You may annoy the fuck out of everyone around you if you are actually successful, and it's important to be in a social environment where people are tolerant of perfectionism and thrive from it. It's just called being devoted. It doesn't have to be trivialized to a pejorative and mapped to a set of things approximately related to whatever goal you define. People can pick up on all of these things and get it wrong because unless you explain to them the point of all your work they won't necessarily understand it. It's then easy to internalize their issues as your own, which can implicitly shift your own standards, preferences. 'Better' in comparison to others is a state of mind that is ultimately destructive. If you like details and like feeling a sense of progress you define, better is perfectly fine to want to be. Muted, dull sameness has it's own tormented unchanging cyclical state that can be just as challenging to direct oneself out of once you convince yourself into it.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
- electrograv 8y agoThis paragraph, which seems to summarize much of this article’s position, seems quite dangerous: > Perfectionism is a personality trait rather than a mental health condition. There is no World Health Organization diagnosis code for perfectionism and it is not listed in the American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. It can fly under the radar and masquerade as the pursuit of high standards, yet it overlaps with a plethora of disorders from eating to obsessive-compulsive disorder, anxiety, body dysmorphia, depression and suicide. Note how it simultaneously says “perfectionism is not a mental health condition”, then proceeds to immediately insuinate it is effectively a mental disorder. This continues throughout the rest of the article. The domain of neurodiversity as a whole is far more complex than reducing the whole of a phenomenon to such simplistic and IMO damagingly derogatory terms as “interolerable rise of perfectionism”. Despite the author’s attempt to interleave a few studies with personal stories, it conveniently neglects to tell the stories of “happy perfectionism”: There are many like myself, for whom pursuing this internal motivation for perfectionism turns out to be immensely intrinsically rewarding. In fact, I believe this intrinsic pleasure some (small percentage of the population) take from striving for perfection to have played (and continues to play) a pivotal role in humanity’s rise in technological advancement. It is not the destination, but the journey (to asymptotically approach a vision of perfection), that healthy perfectionists find so rewarding. Certainly, pathological corruptions of perfectionism exist (for example, any such case where you experience distress or suffering for not achieving infinite perfection, despite it being obviously unattainable) — but this is true for all personality traits.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- s-shellfish 8y agoEverything is a mental health condition these days. Honestly I think the mental health care industry is getting nervous over how complex, diverse and non-trivial it is to understand minds. It's easy for the field to operate on the premise 'but these poor people, we are trying to help them!'. It's at the least, a bit absurd to be hypercritical over every little detail of thinking, acting, behaving, processing, etc and consider that 'help'. I agree with you that perfectionism doesn't have to be a bad thing. It seems more that one has to be cautious with who one displays those characteristics towards because it can easily provocate insecurity in others, unintentionally. Which can be a totally reasonable reaction, life sometimes sucks and happens and things one wants to be devoted to may have to be deprioritized. But if you want to be a perfectionist and are in a place in life where you can afford to devote yourself that much, then you shouldn't let the fact that other people made different choices get to you to the point that it halts your own ability to progress.
- carlmr 8y agoI've made a similar realization early on in my studies. If I learn a lot more things than necessary, but only imperfectly I do much better in the same time than someone who learned exactly what is necessary but perfectly. Because you often make extra connections and discoveries when you go beyond what is required. This is one reason why I think we need a school reform where exams aren't rated as much on perfectionism, but more on broad knowledge. I.e. if you can only solve a part of the questions but more of the questions then you can still receive a good grade. Basically make the tests longer and more broad than what you expect and give 150% of the points. That way you can either solve 2/3 like normal, or you solve more of the problems imperfectly and get the same result. It allows for more learning styles. This way you could probably cover much more knowledge in a shorter time frame. Because a lot of the imperfect knowledge will get better over time eventually when you learn knowledge that builds upon it.
- j_b_s 8y agoIra Glass: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X2wLP0izeJE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X2wLP0izeJE This guy is perfect.
- selimthegrim 8y agoAs long as you're not his dog or a potential victim of his dog.
- milesokeefe 8y agoContext: https://www.petful.com/pet-health/ira-glass-dog-piney/ https://www.petful.com/pet-health/ira-glass-dog-piney/
- Koshkin 8y agoIn my experience, perfectionism is a reaction to a lack of actual progress or success. Kind of similar to forms of idealism or religious feelings that arise as a result of being powerless in the face of circumstances.
- cryoshon 8y agoyou've made an eminently prescient comment here. it explains why many scientists are self-denying and perfectionistic: failure is the rule during experimentation, and progress is not guaranteed or even knowable sometimes. i think that eventually it gets inseparable from the person. the reaction becomes a habit, and then it sticks.
- xtf 8y agoI've seen "What Happens When A Night Owl Is Forced To Live Like An Early Bird"[0] yesterday and wonder how it correlates with this. It basically says that 27% of the population are night owls and are in an evolutionary sense our natural night watch and when forced into a daytime schedule, always tired. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_kZVbE_coSA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_kZVbE_coSA
- TheAceOfHearts 8y agoRather tangential to this, but I've always had trouble getting up early and maintaining that schedule. A little over a month ago I changed my diet to reduce carbs as much as possible, and I've never felt so alert and awake. Waking up early went from a grueling task to something that just happens naturally. I know this is just one anecdote, but I wonder if some of the mentioned people might also benefit from trying different diets.
- slededit 8y agowhenever someone brings up the fact a sizeable portion of the population is forced into an unnatural sleep rythm; inevitably someone will chime in with a "I forced myself with method X and now I'm normal". It completely misses the underlying point.
- fjsolwmv 8y agoIgnoring the terrible effects of carbs on health also misses the point. Parent didn't say anything about forcing.
- naasking 8y agoI'm not sure it does. Their "natural" habits aren't necessarily all that natural either. For all you know, a diet change really did correct an underlying issue causing the strange habit.
- slededit 8y ago
- jhoechtl 8y agoWhile the title touched me, less did the article itself. I thought it would be more about working conditions which at least for me and with control and checks everywhere in place leaves less and less space for humans to err, favouring perfectionists.
- mgamache 8y ago"perfectionism" as it's used here seems like just optimizing your life around a narrow set of criteria.
- laurex 8y agoThis article reflects a view that "perfectionism" is the cause of anxiety, depression, and social insecurity. It seems more likely that self-destructive perfectionism (since positive perfectionism is framed here as well) is a result of anxiety and social insecurity, not the other way around.
- ruok0101 8y agoMaybe I've been working with too many millennials lately, but personally, I wish more people I worked with were perfectionists! My subjective observation is overall commitment to quality has generally decrease over the last decade of my career. I know I have OCD tendencies, and I've found that if I can harness it properly (mostly by just being aware of when I am in a obsessive state) I can really internalize the topic at hand and add the new knowledge/skill to my everyday repertoire.
- Raidion 8y agoI think the problem I have with perfectionism, is that in a fairly connected world of 7+ billion people, the people that get "acclaim" are truly some of the most talented/lucky/good people in the world. You never see mediocrity anymore, everyone has curated Instagram and Facebook feeds of their best moments. If you do see it, it's the process of something like America's Got Talent where it's laughed at. Dave Grohl of the Foo Fighters said it really well [0]. Everyone that we see doing almost anything online is really really good at it, so people get intimidated that they can't do what 8 year old prodigies are doing. There is such a gap between good and great that people are afraid of taking the time to make the jump since the other side feels so far away. It's ok to be bad at things, it's ok if your art or passion doesn't change the world. It's ok if you enjoy the journey and the destination isn't the top of the charts or a world championship in whatever. [0] https://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/the-hot-button/dave-grohl-rants-its-destroying-the-next-generation-of-musicians/article11746664/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/the-hot-button/dave-gro...
- some_account 8y agoSolution: Stop watching TV and stop following celebrities and social media. They call it TV programming for a reason. Not everyone is curating profiles, not everyone cares what other people are doing, not everybody wants to be told what to think from someone else. But you will never know if you don't turn that shit off and start to do what you want to do without fear.
- blt 8y agograduate school has been crushing in this way.
- darpa_escapee 8y agoIf you ever get the chance to peek behind the curtain of these superstar online personas, it's refreshing to say the least. People like to imagine that most gained popularity organically, but there's a lot of expensive marketing, gaming of algorithms and outright cheating (paying for followers/comments/reviews/likes, paying other personas to promote their own without disclosure etc). It's a reminder that there are probably a lot of very capable, talented people out there who aren't as dedicated to making an online presence for themselves.
- yandrypozo 8y agoRise of perfectionism? I'm actually noticing a decline on aiming for perfection. I can't stop recommending this talk: https://www.ted.com/talks/jon_bowers_we_should_aim_for_perfection_and_stop_fearing_failure https://www.ted.com/talks/jon_bowers_we_should_aim_for_perfe...
- sequoia 8y agoIs anyone else struggling to feel sorry for these high achieving graduate students because they, what, feel bad sometimes? > ‘Even exercise doesn’t sound like a total escape for Tom Nicol: he is training to beat his dad’s personal best mile time.’ Oh wow, training to beat another runner's time. What pathos, what suffering! Give me a break.