10 ms·
Any civilization that has mastered interstellar travel will almost certainly also have mastered atomic transmutation as well. So as long as all the interesting
by lisper 8y ago
Any civilization that has mastered interstellar travel will almost certainly also have mastered atomic transmutation as well. So as long as all the interesting stuff is made of atoms, and the atoms over there are the same as the ones over here (which AFAWCT they are), there are only two possible "goods" that could be worth transporting between star systems: information, and free (in the physical, not the economic sense) energy. You don't need a space ship to transfer either of those, you just convert them into photons and let Maxwell do the work. The idea that it might be worthwhile to actually ship something (including ourselves) to another star system is based on very quaint notions of identity binding and what it takes to produce things.
- squirrelicus 8y agoWhere I think you're wrong is that you seem to assume there's a path to arbitrary transmutation. It may not be possible, and I would argue, almost certainly isn't.
- gibybo 8y agoDo you see some fundamental limit other than energy?
- squirrelicus 8y agoContainment, which is somewhat of a practical limit, and somewhat fundamental. Now I'm no fusion expert, and frankly neither is any human since we can barely get tiny amounts of hydrogen to fuse at all. But point being, I'm not a physicist, I'm in software. So take my understanding with a grain of salt. However, while we theoretically can fuse arbitrary elements (and add neutrons for heavier elements so they don't instantly decay), I'm pretty sure there's no known, theoretical, or speculated material or process that can contain and capture the results of fusing some elements to, say, uranium. The extraordinary energy levels required pretty much means you need a supernova. And I'm not one to suggest that in the future we'll magically be able to engineer something to contain supernovae. Quite the opposite, I'm comfortable saying no civilization will ever do this no matter how many quintillion years they try. All this being said, there is definitely an inflection point where it costs orders of magnitude less energy to mine an element and rocket it to a destination than to fuse it on demand. Sometimes people complain that this takes time and we need the thing now, but that's fine. Once you set up the supply line, all that really matters is throughout and interruptions, since arbitrary latency can be overcome by a continuous stream of material floating to you. I mean, sure, it'll cost latency to ramp up or down the stream, but if engineering is One Thing, it's trade offs. Reality's a bitch like that.
- avian 8y ago> I'm pretty sure there's no known, theoretical, or speculated material or process that can contain and capture the results of fusing some elements to, say, uranium. Producing heavy elements in a lab is most certainly possible right now. You don’t need a supernova, just a particle accelerator. Many elements heavier than uranium have been created artificially this way. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transuranium_element https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transuranium_element
- squirrelicus 8y agoYou're right. But synthesizing enough material to be relevant to an industrial effort is a leap of engineering so large as to be beyond our capacity to imagine its possibility.
- cinquemb 8y agoWith the way that resource allocation seems to be bound by presently, if there was a war, and one/some group could some how get the resources to scale up such processes if they could seriously convince the war planners of its "super weapon" capabilities, I could see it happening even if it took a couple years to get a working prototype at scale (depending on its ability to not compete sufficiently with other resources for war to not purse such project at all). And seeing that humans haven't came up with the abilities to avoid war completely, it's only a matter of time (which may be a lot for an individual humans lifespan).
- sixo 8y ago> will almost certainly also have mastered atomic transmutation as well I don't see any reason to think that's true.
- jack9 8y agoWhy not? We started atomic transmutation with fire.
- squirrelicus 8y agoChemical reactions are a subset of atomic transmutation. Arbitrary atomic transmutation is likely a superset of all possible atomic transmutations Categories. It's all categories.
- jack9 8y agoIt's likely the superset of some transmutations. Categories or not, one precedes the other (for anything that we understand).
- lisper 8y agoWhy not? If stars can do it, why not a sufficiently advanced civilization?
- m_mueller 8y agoWhat indicates that Interstellar travel requires a technological level that includes arbitrary transmutation? It seems to me travelling these distances is much simpler, it basically just requires current technology plus organisations that can hold together for more than a century or so. If you take the only known civilisation as an example: Ever since the invention of atomic bombs we have the propulsion part of what's required to go to ~40% the speed of light (or ~20% and then break). The most difficult challenge yet to overcome would probably be the front shield (at relativistic speeds, space dust can really mess things up), but that seems far from unsolvable. The main thing missing is political will to take the required risks. We were well on a path to such a machine in the 60ies, what failed was mainly politics in the two organisations large and advanced enough to do it (USGov/UdSSR).
- mlindner 8y agoYou don't think there would be any trade in antiques? Even in the modern world, just because we can reproduce something exactly doesn't mean there are many people willing to spend lots of money on something that is unreproducible.
- sounds 8y agoA lot of the value of antiques comes from the lost knowledge they represent, whether that's just sentimental "you just had to be there" experiences or more concrete "you don't know how to make the varnish on a Stradivarius" lost knowledge. For that matter, the distances between systems creates a sort of time-travel effect. You receive their knowledge hundreds of years after the fact, making it implicitly "antique lost knowledge." So I think the point still stands that all trade would be done using photons. I would be very interested to discuss how "trade done using photons" is such a 21st-century concept and that it bears as much resemblance to interstellar trade as the black pepper trade of the 13th-century proscribes capital markets today.
- lisper 8y agoWell, I hope that any civilization that masters interstellar travel would have moved beyond such foolishness. If you can produce an atom-by-atom duplicate, what does it even mean for something to be "the original"? http://blog.rongarret.info/2015/02/31-flavors-of-ontology.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2015/02/31-flavors-of-ontology.ht...
- ThomPete 8y agoIt means that it has history attached to it and that it's traveled in time. Humans will most certainly not abandon things of affectional value our lives and most value in life is built up around that. Why do you think you have different levels of friends? History is very important to us.
- lisper 8y agoYou clearly did not read the article I linked to.
- kcanini 8y ago> AFAWKT "As far as we KAN tell"?
- Robotbeat 8y agoI used to think that was true. But then I researched practical interstellar travel methods (not quite relativistic, 0.1c), and they seem doable from a physics and engineering perspective (if you controlled the world's wealth), but we have no real executable plan to build a transporter.
- squirrelicus 8y agoNot to mention that transporters (disassembler/reassemblers) are (a) murder machines, and (b) cloning machines.
- ddingus 8y agoHa! As far as I can tell, this "me" and that "you" exchanging thoughts right now, are one offs, a delicate state, aware. One day, cloning, assumung we can do it in a non destrucrive way, and I am not convinced that will ever be true, would make another one. That one will diverge quickly from us as it's experiences would differ. I am not convinced it is possible to avoid that happening either. The transporter is such an interesting idea! But, using it would have to come with a bit different idea and acceptance of identity. The idea of a "me" continuing on, doing what I would have done, is plausible. The shared experiences make for a reality, also shared. That is where identity would lie. To understand if we are talking to a Kirk, post transport, our validation would basically be done with what is known, shared among those asking the question. It is all like sleeping, only to wonder if the same person awakens. In terms of a body holding a state, stream of experiences, yes. But, in terms of that person, as in would they pass the "talking to Kirk?" test, perhaps not. Ever meet someone after a coma, or even long surgery and experience a lack of congruence? Does not always happen, but it can. That is an example of that state being changed, yet the stream of experiences remaining intact. (As much as it can during times of long sleep, coma, and so forth)
- squirrelicus 8y agoNot to trivialize the great unsolved question of WTF is consciousness... I think it's a bit easier to reason about this problem than you think. For example, generally Star Trek wants us to presume the murder and cloning occur simultaneously. Let's say they don't. In the case that the murder occurs before the cloning, the waters are admittedly still muddy. Is it, in fact, like waking up from a sleep? Not very easy to tell. However, if we presume that the murder occurs after the cloning, things become quite clear. There can definitely only be one physical me in which I am conscious -- I feel comfortable rejecting an assertion that I would experience multiple simultaneous consciousnesses of a sequence of atomwise clones. Therefore, we work backwards. If I can't experience more than one consciousness simultaneously, then I can't experience two. If you clone me, I am not that clone, I am still the original. As the time between cloning and murdering (t) approaches zero, the same holds true. I am comfortable asserting there's nothing special about consciousness that would cause instantaneous consciousness transfer as (t) reaches zero and then becomes negative. Therefore a transporter clone will not be me from my perspective. Therefore the murder is my death, and the cloning is a birth of a new completely separate consciousness that I will never experience.
- nathanathan 8y agoCells might be worth transporting. Although the DNA can be sent as data and reconstructed, de novo reconstruction of the rest of the cellular machinery needed to run the DNA might not be practical.
- antt 8y agoA seed universal constructor would be worth transporting. If that is a machine or a ship with cryogenically frozen human of all ages is a topic for another day.
- incadenza 8y agoAnd human beings, and good luck convincing anybody to jump into one of those things...mostly because doing so is more or less dying.
- Johnny555 8y agoIt's very inexpensive to create nearly exact replicas of artwork, yet people are still willing to pay a lot of money for the original. So maybe people will be willing to pay lots of money for hand-crafted alien artwork.
- tomrod 8y agoPerhaps that's the great filter before us: can we learn to appreciate sans ownership?
- commieneko 8y agoThat is similar to the answer I came up with in high school, about 40 years ago. Artwork, objects of note, curiosities with provenances, tourists, off the grid information that needs to remain _really_ secure, spies, traitors, patriots, displaced peoples, artefacts bound to a religious, gifts, bodies, deceased bodies, prenatal bodies, slaves, sex objects, objects of devotion, objects of derision, pariahs. I actually wrote a short story about a trade empire that was built by a race of aliens (they looked like lizards) that had odd religious beliefs that required them to build monasteries all over the galaxy, and staff them with praying monks. The monk's duties were very simple, each day they had to silently read from a small paper prayer, then burn the strip of paper over a candle. The rest of the day they partied, got drunk, had sex (monks could be of either gender), or wrote non-prayer literature. Writing prayers was an unforgivable sin, the prayers had to come from the home planet. There was a huge fleet of trade ships created to deliver the paper prayer strips in bulk. In return for the land for the monasteries, the alien lizards would give rides on their space fleet. They had single use vouchers that went from point to point, and they had travel passes which allowed general travel. Basically a bus pass for the galaxy. And since they had a monopoly on FTL ships, they delivered mail. One day the prayer ships stopped coming. Everybody goes bananas. Nobody travels. Economies collapse. Plus somebody has to feed the monks, and keep them entertained or else they go on party binges. Can't let them starve, because the ships might start coming again. A generation later the ships start showing up again. No explanation given, and it's impolite to ask. The kind of impolite that gets you cut out of the prayer circuit. That was all backstory, the actual story starts with an undercover agent from Earth getting sent to the lizard homeworld to try and find out WTF. He only has partial passage and a small consignment of trade goods. The backstory got backfilled as the agent wheeled and dealed his way towards the home world. I did have an ending, but I think I'll not spoil it in case I ever want to try and rewrite the story. My 17 year old prose stank, unsurprisingly; even at that tender age I could smell it. Not sure I can do better now, but who knows.
- credit_guy 8y agoSending light across interstellar distances is not a trivial affair. No light source is perfectly collimated; per wikipedia [1] "The divergence of high-quality laser beams is commonly less than 1 milliradian, and can be much less for large-diameter beams". Not clear how "much less" is (and I couldn't find other sources), but let's say it's 2-3 more orders of magnitude. That would make it about 1 arc second (~5 microradians). The closest star is at a distance of about one parsec, which means that two photons starting here and having an angle of 1 arc second between them end up at a distance of 1 AU (astronomical unit ~ 150 MM km) between them. Assuming you can make an antenna the size of Jupiter at the target, for every photon that passes through that antenna you need to send 1 million photons. Every order of magnitude lower in the size of the antenna requires you to send two orders of magnitude more photons. In other words, an antenna 1% the size of Jupiter requires you to send 10 billion photons for each photon received. You can get around that by setting up a system of relays, but you will end up needing lots of relays, and that's a complex infrastructure you need to maintain. In any case, even after we master inter-stellar travel, don't think we'll have channels of communication of terabytes/second, every byte will be expensive to send across. Sending information in the quantities needed to 3d-print stuff at atomic level will most likely be prohibitively expensive; remember 1 gram of hydrogen contains 10^23 atoms, while one terabyte only contains 10^12 bytes. If a little latency is acceptable, it will always be many times cheaper to just send the stuff you need rather than the information to 3d-print it at atomic level. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collimated_light https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Collimated_light
- lisper 8y ago> Sending light across interstellar distances is not a trivial affair. I never said it was. But it's a hell of a lot easier (to say nothing of faster and more efficient) than sending matter.
- credit_guy 8y agoNot necessarily. Remember, photons have mass. Sending a lot of them means you perform mass transfer. Since photons are not parallel, that transfer is not efficient. It's probably much more efficient to send a small package equipped with a large solar sail and push it from behind with a big laser until it reaches a relativistic speed, then decelerate it on the other side with another big laser.
- cinquemb 8y ago>The idea that it might be worthwhile to actually ship something (including ourselves) to another star system is based on very quaint notions of identity binding and what it takes to produce things. I often think that the forms we take on now aren't suited for space travel (unless you consider living on a planet that is in motion through space as space travel) much less staying in low earth orbit for a year. We have to bend backwards to engineer materials to shield our presently fragile bodies, imo quite futilely, from the harshness of space. I think we'd be much better off modifying our bodies (or even rethinking what constitutes a body/form) to be able to withstand this harshness, at least in the interim before we can build a system that can somehow propagate energy FTL, though I definitely think we should pursue the latter, as the benefits could be realized on earth.
- hackeraccount 8y agoYou're probably right but arguably sending traditional sense goods is in a certain sense sending information and energy i a single package. With enough density it might make more sense to ship the good then the energy and information used to create it.
- dalore 8y agoSome people would value getting an original whatever item and would pay a premium for shipping, rather then just getting it replicated. Extremely wealthy people would show off all the original non replicated items they posses from far away civilizations.
- lisper 8y agoThat is only true because we don't yet have the technology for making atomically perfect copies of physical objects. No one pays a premium for "the original" of a digital image.