6 ms·
> Interesting thought: Do Facebook, Google, etc have "users" and not "customers" for their consumer products? Advertisers are the customers. Non-advertisers ar
by masklinn 8y ago
> Interesting thought: Do Facebook, Google, etc have "users" and not "customers" for their consumer products?
Advertisers are the customers. Non-advertisers are the product. The goal is not to provide a good service to the product, it's to drive engagement of the product up so customers are happy.
- augbog 8y agoDamn... this hit me hard and makes me realize why corporations can be pretty evil :/... in the back of their minds, they're always thinking of how to please their "true" customers.
- tskaiser 8y agoCorporations, at least the for-profit ones, are principally amoral legal constructs, which I find all the more terrifying than the notion that they could be evil. Insomuch as they can be anthropomorphized they don't even truly care about whatever their 'customers' are or their well-being, so long as the bottom line is optimized across time. The rank and file humans that make up the functions of a corporation might be moral and may influence the corporation to make 'irrational' choices due to human morality, but that is not the rule.
- lgregg 8y ago> Corporations, at least the for-profit ones, are principally amoral legal constructs, which I find all the more terrifying than the notion that they could be evil. I had a pretty spirited argument that was ongoing for about a week with my friend, who was my co-founder at the time, where my position was similar to yours. (Note: this is all in the context of U.S. Law and Government) His argument was that it's impossible for any entity to be amoral because whether a corporation or person, both are treated as persons or entities meaning that they can provide their will. So, once a corporation reaches a point it indeed can be moral because it goes beyond a legal instrument and is dictated by a collective staff, leadership, and/or stakeholders. He would have said that in the case of a solo entrepreneur's company, it would just be an abstracted will of the entrepreneur. I eventually got to the point where I couldn't argue against the legal precedence of Corporate personhood. [0] I think there is a point when a corporation outgrows their founder and becomes self-sustaining where it's corporate culture dictates it's "morals". [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_personhood https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_personhood
- tskaiser 8y agoI agree that a corporation can make what would be perceived as moral actions, exactly due to the human staff running it, but that does not erase that morals does not factor into the objective function that a corporation is meant to optimize. This is exacerbated as the morals of its actions become difficult to analyze for the individual and the moral actions of employees becomes less individually significant. The concerted effort, on which the fitness of the corporation is ultimately measured, will still amount to the optimization of the bottom line. This is especially true when the corporation outgrows the control of its original founders who may have had a moral vision. In the end the analogy I am making is that a corporation has reins, and as it grows it becomes increasingly unwieldy for the handlers (= staff) to direct it where it does not want to go (away from profit). It is of course easy to have a corporation act moral when this objective overlaps with optimization of its objective function. I don't consider such a happy occurrence to qualify as truly moral, however.
- ethbro 8y agoThe franchise and the virus work on the same principle: what thrives in one place will thrive in another. You just have to find a sufficiently virulent business plan, condense it into a three-ring binder — its DNA — xerox it, and embed it in the fertile lining of a well-traveled highway, preferably one with a left-turn lane... - Neal Stephenson, Snow Crash
- jadedhacker 8y agoRemember when everyone was talking about how an amoral AI paperclip optimizer could destroy the planet? We have those, they're called corporations and they optimize dollars.
- AmericanChopper 8y agoFor that to be always true, the customers would have to be amoral too. Many companies find success in differentiating themselves to appeal to morally conscious consumers, and even more companies find themselves having to react to them from time to time.
- tskaiser 8y agoBut that is not moral, is it? The company is still not beholden to a willful idea of morality, but rather sociopathically concerned with appearance. For companies where this matters little this concern for appearance is quickly shed.
- AmericanChopper 8y agoYou could say the same about any social contract. The criticism applies to any person as much as it applies to any company. It’s the same as saying that altruism doesn’t exist because it’s logically impossible to conceive a scenario where an altruistic act doesn’t benefit the actor.
- tskaiser 8y agoA vital difference is that companies do not have a sapient capacity for emotion and empathy.
- hrktb 8y agoBoth are customers though. As long as there is paying tier on the end user side, it is also a customer who has a presence in the decision that are made. To Google’s credit, Youtube Red for instance goes in that direction. Same for Google Suite customers, Google Play users etc. Of course the power balance is tipped toward the companies who are willing to pay more, but that’s a balance, and not a one sided relation. For facebook I think the picture is darker, but then that’s facebook afterall.
- darth_mastah 8y agoThe paying tier are customers (sort of). All the rest are product. It's quite a specific product, because it has to be seduced and tempted by perceived benefits to forfeit its privacy, but still a product it is.
- da_chicken 8y agoNon-advertisers are consumers. That's the term the television industry adopted to differentiate between the two groups.
- johnchristopher 8y ago> Advertisers are the customers. Non-advertisers are the product. The goal is not to provide a good service to the product, it's to drive engagement of the product up so customers are happy. No. Advertisers are the customers of the Facebook Ad product line (Business manager, boost, campaign, pixel facebook). Users of Facebook Social Networking services are prospects tracked by Facebook. 2 products: - the tracking and targeting tools - the social network Users aren't the product. Interfaces to target segments based on users's data is one of the two products Facebook offers.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]