4 ms·
Per Twitch's stream analytics, on one of my data science programming streams on Twitch the majority of my viewers came from the Explore page, under the relative
by minimaxir 8y ago
Per Twitch's stream analytics, on one of my data science programming streams on Twitch the majority of my viewers came from the Explore page, under the relatively-less-popular Programming category.
I wonder if there's a bit of game theory in play where it's impossible to be discovered when playing a megapopular game like Overwatch/Fortnite, and it's more advantageous to play relatively more obscure games. It wouldn't be the first time working the long-tail has been effective.
- nlowell 8y agoAt least for streamers who are already somewhat established, the metagame is actually to move to whichever game is most popular with viewers.
- satsuma 8y agoan interesting side effect of something like that is the hop-ons during the games done quick streams -- often times you'll see streamers switch games to whatever's being played on stream in the hopes someone will... misclick, or get bored and check out the other streams in the game or something. you also see it when a large streamer is playing a relatively unknown game (sodapoppin used to have a semi-weekly stream where he played games subscribers recommended, usually bargain bin or free to play shovelware)
- lev99 8y ago> I wonder if there's a bit of game theory in play where it's impossible to be discovered when playing a megapopular game like Overwatch/Fortnite, and it's more advantageous to play relatively more obscure games. I do not think most twitch streamers are trying to be professionals. I think most streamers are just trying to add more fun into their game time. In game theory everyone's main objective is the same, in this case measured in either revenue or viewers. In the twitch world most streamers are trying to maximize fun instead of viewers or revenue. (Disclosure: I stream relatively obscure games, and know many other streamers in both megapopular and obscure games.)
- prefferot 8y agoReading this made me curious. I'll probably check out the programming category tonight if I have time. How is the quality of those programming streams? What goes on in them? Do the streamers answer questions about techniques, etc? Is it just shoptalk/circlejerking? I'm usually a self-starter on learning things, but I can lose interest quickly if I don't get some sort of feedback or have someone to ask questions. MOOCs, forums, etc are a waste of time for me in most cases; too slow and impersonal. And now that I think about it Twitch/streaming would probably be a better suited learning medium for me.
- rezashirazian 8y agoThe quality is poor. It's mostly gamer streamers trying out something different. They're usually going through a udacity course or hacking a crud web application. There is lot of blindly looking at the screen, reading tutorials or getting frustrated with compilation errors. They do not like to be helped.
- keithnz 8y agoI think this is an unfair characterization, there are some REALLY good programmers, some new programmers, and people at all stages of their programming journey. A lot are doing game programming, I'm less interested in this, but some are very interesting. For instance... https://www.twitch.tv/jessicamak https://www.twitch.tv/jessicamak Really interesting what she does, and an insane attention to detail. A HNer I watch when he codes... he does an interesting mix of stuff and has 30+ years of experience https://www.twitch.tv/nybblesio https://www.twitch.tv/nybblesio there's people coding games with robotic bananas https://www.twitch.tv/uselessduckcompany/videos/all https://www.twitch.tv/uselessduckcompany/videos/all .NET devs https://www.twitch.tv/csharpfritz https://www.twitch.tv/csharpfritz who also has coding streams with Microsoft Devs and numerous others doing embedded development, web development, backend dev, security, crypto, Rust, Lisp, C++, F#, Vimers, IDEers, VSCoders, Emacers.... all sorts. who
- rezashirazian 8y agoMy comment was based on random visits to /programming and checking out what people were doing. I didn't know of the streamers you mentioned, but I'd be sure to check them out. Looking forward to being wrong on this.
- jmcgough 8y agoYep. I get almost no one finding me when I play hearthstone, but I always have ~10 viewers when I stream speedrun attempts of popular snes games. It really is a matter of finding your niche when you start out.
- stale2002 8y agoSame here, actually. It turns out that if you do the basics, and make content that is not terrible, then you can be the "#1 live stream programmer in the world", pretty easily. But it turns out that getting to the #1 spot at the top of the twitch programming category only nets you about 10-20 concurrent viewers. At that point the goal should be to grow the category as a whole, I guess.
- drchickensalad 8y agoIt's definitely true for some people I know because it gets you above the fold for the game/category. Most people watch above the fold in browse, and then above the fold for those games, so the streamers get all or nothing depending on the fold. So when you start out, that's nothing. But for the minority of people who care about specific games/categories that usually aren't above the fold on browse (which hn is probably biased towards), this gets you quite consistent growth and engagement, especially if you're competant at the game or interacting.