2 ms·
I don't think there was ever a scientific consensus among people who actually studied Rapa Nui and anthropology that Rapa Nui had an ecological collapse before
by jcranmer 8y ago
I don't think there was ever a scientific consensus among people who actually studied Rapa Nui and anthropology that Rapa Nui had an ecological collapse before the arrival of Europeans. (The introduction of Europeans and sheep grazing did contribute to a subsequent ecological collapse, but the indications are that Rapa Nui was considered very fertile when Europeans first arrive).
The loudest proponent of this theory is Jared Diamond, whose credibility among anthropologists is somewhere between non-existent and negative. Given the popularity of his books Guns, Germs, and Steel and Collapse (the latter of which is particularly egregious in cherry-picking evidence and making stuff up to support his hypothesis), I suspect that's where your evidence came from. The centerpieces of ecological self-destruction--Maya, Rapa Nui, and Norse Greenland--are all not supported by the available evidence. (The cause of Mayan collapse is not agreed-upon, but the climate thesis is problematic since the more marginal sites lasted far longer than the less marginal; Rapa Nui, as noted above, didn't collapse in the suggested timeframe; and Norse Greenland died out when it was dropped from trade routes, not when the environment changed).