4 ms·
Most (human) languages have a set of rules and a variant set of variances ("i before e except after c, and this catalog of things which we pretend don't exist")
by ggm 8y ago
Most (human) languages have a set of rules and a variant set of variances ("i before e except after c, and this catalog of things which we pretend don't exist")
so ML and NLP are cases of things which are ameanable to rules based systems, and because english corpus exists widely can be tested openly, against each other and a common norm of comprehension (for english speakers)
generalized AI does not lie here: systems which uncover the grammer rules and exceptions do not generalize to systems which uncover rules in Law, or Equity, or financial trading, or other things. Yes, you can train nets. But the commonality here, is you can train, not that emergent AI is found.
(not an AI person, strongly anti-AI perspective from life experience in compsci)
- fny 8y agoIs there such a thing as AGI really though instead of collections of modules that are trained and may have no meaningful mode of interaction? What does NLP have to do with the mathematics of financial trading? AGI has always felt to me as a large scale interdisciplinary/intercomputational activity, much in the same way that most human intelligence derived from years of intergenerational and interpersonal intellectual development. AGI will never be one but many: many intelligences and systems interacting to produce something of utlitarian value.
- ggm 8y agomuch in the same way that most human intelligence derived from years of intergenerational and interpersonal intellectual development. wow! I had no idea the archeology on early hominids was that good... (yes, implicit /s)
- taeric 8y agoThis treats human language as a somewhat static thing that can be fully specified. Which, interestingly, avoids a large portion of human languages in poetry and metaphor. A bit like judging story telling by only accounting true stories, thus completely ignoring all of fiction. Saying nothing of false stories purported as true. It is quite possible that understanding is nothing more than a statistical relating of otherwise unrelated things. Some things, we accept as being 100% related. But, quite a lot of things are just "highly related." Where "highly" is probably not specified.