3 ms·
I agree with the substantive thrust of this comment, but disagree with elitism being a necessary prerequisite for it being true. For one thing, you may be unde
by patio11 16y ago
I agree with the substantive thrust of this comment, but disagree with elitism being a necessary prerequisite for it being true.
For one thing, you may be under the impression that you -- the broad "you", HN users in general -- read on the Internet. You don't. You are a paragraph-skimming button-clicking satisficing ADHD squirrel like everyone else is. Your behavior is trivially influenced by A/B tests, and you lack sufficient insight to notice it. You click on shiny buttons. You do what calls to action tell you to do, and are exquisitely sensitive to their wording. You respond to advertising. You probably don't eat chicken McNuggets, because you think only poor people eat chicken McNuggets, and you don't even remember why you think that.
- jdietrich 16y agoI agree with you to an extent - we certainly fall for most of the same psychological tricks. We are also clearly exceptional as a demographic. We are dramatically better educated and more literate than the mean. We're mostly male, whereas the internet is now a female majority population[1]. There is evidence to show that we behave very differently when presented with long-form content[2]. While I'm perfectly prepared to accept that our actual preferences are far more homogenous than our expressed preferences, I think the predominant error made by "our kind" is forgetting just how strange we are as a group and as individuals, at least in terms of our abilities and our expressed preferences. As regards 'elitism', I've seen an awful lot of startups fail because they overestimated their users, but never once seen one that underestimates them. Amongst the HN community, people's first reaction to Bingo Card Creator seemed to be "who the hell pays money for that?". If it takes a bit of arrogance and disdain for us to grok the level of the average user, then so be it - no offence to HNers, but we're not exactly overflowing with humility are we? [1] http://www.emarketer.com/Report.aspx?code=emarketer_2000574 http://www.emarketer.com/Report.aspx?code=emarketer_2000574 [2] http://binarybonsai.com/2010/09/27/chewie-stats/ http://binarybonsai.com/2010/09/27/chewie-stats/