2 ms·
DeDeo's argument seems to be a philosophical one: If you want to build machines that monitor people and sell them more ads faster, go for it. If you want to fi
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
DeDeo's argument seems to be a philosophical one:
If you want to build machines that monitor people and sell them more ads faster, go for it. If you want to find problem where you can take a working-class job, model the man or woman who does it, and build a net to put them out of a job without compensation, be my guest.
A major divisive narrative I see in ML/AI is whether philosophical questions as to the ends of the work are worthy of time.
This is starkest in the debate about providing ML based solutions to governments. Some group says "we're not on board philosophically" the others shrug and move on.
I don't think this is much different than any other engineering/science discipline honestly.
So I think DeDeo, as part of academia is trying to say: Academia has knowledge as it's ultimate goal, corporations just have profit and product. So therefore:
"But if you want, at some point in your flourishing career, with your mind and your soul, to join the two-thousand year old parade of intellectual progress, you are not going to do it at Google."
The strongly negative response, I think is in part because it's derisive of corporate work, but also because there seems to be a bias for the idea that "I'm not interested in the philosophy around why I am doing this work"