3 ms·
I confess I was tempted to take a pass on this one. In large, because I've fatigued a lot on reading about AI and Machine Learning. Didn't help that this is a
by taeric 8y ago
I confess I was tempted to take a pass on this one. In large, because I've fatigued a lot on reading about AI and Machine Learning. Didn't help that this is a large article.
That said, I encourage everyone to give this more than a single pass. There is irony that we are, to this day, still quoting and agreeing with Feynman's Cargo Cult Science piece. It is almost disheartening to see that we still have a hard time listening to advice from the early 1970s. By and large, though, this piece does a great job really laying out what makes it so hard to level most criticisms at AI related studies. The cross disciplinary look is one I wouldn't have thought to do, but really does explain a lot.
I'm torn, because I'm sympathetic to most of the defenses. It is hard to really believe we are making meaningful progress, though. Even if I am enjoying many of the small practical improvements we have managed to get out of things.
- Erlich_Bachman 8y agoWhat would "meaningful progress" entail for you? How would your life change, how would the life on earth in general change? Great achievements in science (aided by AI)?
- taeric 8y agoThat is a different question, though. The question if if there is meaningful progress in ai. The amount of progress explained solely by percentage improvements against a benchmark is pretty high. I don't think this is particularly damning. Nor do I think it should be halted. However, I agree it is hard to call progress.
- Erlich_Bachman 8y agoWhat specifically would be easy for you to call progress?
- taeric 8y agoAn equation that could predict a better ML model. Honestly, I think claiming I want an equation is a touch too much. However, a falsifiable prediction would be nice. Imagine if the only way we got accurate ballistics was by requiring faster more powerful guns all of the time. "We can hit the target, but only if we upgrade our guns to railguns and limit ourselves to large targets."