3 ms·
> "One of the primary ways in which charity performance is measured today is on the percentage of money, from operating budget, spent on benefit programs, and n
by chiefalchemist 8y ago
> "One of the primary ways in which charity performance is measured today is on the percentage of money, from operating budget, spent on benefit programs, and not on administrative expenses."
The problem is, this is flawed. It's the wrong KPI. It's the wrong carrot.
For example, in order to maximize this ratio, the NPO "hires" an volunteer to design and build their website. Unfortunately, this person, while kind hearted and generous, is not very talented / experienced.
Long to short, the website "loses" over $500 per week in donations. Had the NPO paid for a better site their ROI and general goodwill would be much better.
Btw, the NPO does the same for their social media marketing. More "opportunity" is left on the table.
Chasing the false god of mission to admin ratio __is__ one of the key mindsets that undermine plenty of NPOs.
- antpls 8y agoBut some donators may agree to hire an inefficient volunteer, you can't tell that everyone agree with that cult of performance. > Long to short, the website "loses" over $500 per week in donations. Had the NPO paid for a better site their ROI and general goodwill would be much better. That's hard to prove. Anyway, what we could do is forcing NGO at even more transparency, and then provide tools to donator to compare them from all points of view. We should give more tools to donators, not investors.
- Vinnl 8y agoOr NGOs stop hiring secretaries because they're "overhead", leading to those being best at providing aid being overburdened with administrative tasks.
- solatic 8y ago> For example, in order to maximize this ratio, the NPO "hires" an volunteer to design and build their website. Unfortunately, this person, while kind hearted and generous, is not very talented / experienced... Long to short, the website "loses" over $500 per week in donations. Had the NPO paid for a better site their ROI and general goodwill would be much better. If a professional will prove to be a net-benefit to the non-profit (bringing in more donations than their salary) then in terms of benefit spend ratios, good charities have a hard floor of no less than 50%. In truth, if a creative professional is really worth their paycheck, then they're bringing in donations worth at least some multiple of their paycheck, which amortized across the charity, creates a soft floor somewhere around the 70-80% mark. Saying that benefit-to-admin ratios are bad measures is like saying that code coverage is a bad measure - it's only a bad measure if you're trying to max it out at 100%. Running a charity completely off volunteer work is clearly infeasible, even if the overhead that volunteers introduce seems to be zero from a surface-level, pure bean-counting, balance-sheet perspective. It's also, in effect, advocating for closing the books of NGOs. Mission-to-admin ratios, even if we take for argument's sake that they are poor ratios for management to focus on, are important to donors for obvious reasons. So arguing that NGOs can do better by not focusing on a metric that they are required by law to report and is squarely within donor interest is arguing to not need for the metric to be reported, so that the NGO can spend without judgement and hit some theoretical global max. Of course, allowing NGOs to close their books would be a disastrous incentive for fraud, embezzlement, and worse. So if the metric will exist, and will be focused on, good financing schemes will work with that metric in mind instead of wishing it didn't exist.
- chiefalchemist 8y ago> "...it's only a bad measure if you're trying to max it out at 100%." That's the point. If that metric is a KPI - and often it is - it can be taken to a counter productive extreme. Which __does__ happen
- mrmanner 8y ago> Long to short, the website "loses" over $500 per week in donations. Had the NPO paid for a better site their ROI and general goodwill would be much better. > Btw, the NPO does the same for their social media marketing. More "opportunity" is left on the table. This is true in the cases where the money not spent with this organization is spent either with a less efficient (by some metric) organization, or on non-charitable causes such as a new car or a new cat for the potential donor instead. If the more expensive website simply relocates charitable donations from one important cause to another, the total goo might actually decrease even if the ROI on the website was good for the individual organization. If an investment brings in "new" money, it's obviously worthwile. I guess my point is that it's good to compare organizations on various metrics, but not to the degree where they start using their resources to outcompete each other instead of doing good.
- chiefalchemist 8y agoMeasurement / incentive __always__ runs the risk of "be careful what you wish for." The idea that the mentioned ratio creates more good is a bad assumption.