2 ms·
> Isn't it now the investors that will make sure non-profits reach their goals? The big question then becomes why should a solely ROI-focused underwriter be be
by notahacker 8y ago
> Isn't it now the investors that will make sure non-profits reach their goals?
The big question then becomes why should a solely ROI-focused underwriter be better at this type of evaluation than a philanthropic foundation which (i) is actively interested in the goals (and probably also related goals/drawbacks not specified as metrics) to the extent of intending to lose money towards achieving them and (ii) likely to be a source of further funding, which means the nonprofit is more motivated both to engage with them and to actually hit the goals
- zxcmx 8y agoAs an investor, why would I invest in a non-profit with difficult-to-game metrics... Because juking the stats or a bit of weaselling in the way goals are stated is way easier and more reliable than building things or say, achieving actual health outcomes. I’m somewhat skeptical.
- Vinnl 8y agoThat is indeed a good question. That said, I don't think the underwriters should be ROI-focused - my interpretation is that current donors would be underwriters. This is a way for them to transfer the risk of what measures will result in what improvements to investors. Evaluation could be as broad as "polio should be eradicated". But yeah, there's a lot of questions left, and I don't feel like I have a good grasp on what this would entail and all its advantages either.