4 ms·
Demand Media (and other ad-focused sites, but most remarkably their operation) understand this deep in their bones, which is why their content is to writing wha
by patio11 16y ago
Demand Media (and other ad-focused sites, but most remarkably their operation) understand this deep in their bones, which is why their content is to writing what chicken McNuggets are to chicken.
- RBr 16y agoI had a number of conversations about this exact sentiment when I was writing for Mahalo. I came to understand that there is a balance between writing enough information that users found an article helpful but not so much information that they would not want to click on ads or related pages. The problem of course is that when one is encouraged to write almost completely with profit and clicks in mind that eventually, their body of work becomes devalued by the audience.
- vaksel 16y agoyeah those guys are scum Search for "recover notepad files" and the first Google result is "How to Recover an Unsaved Notepad File | eHow.com " and then the whole article is about how you can't recover the file...with 4 adsense links at the end with most having click worthy titles like "recover deleted files" so Google users get screwed, Google advertisers get screwed, and eHow and Google both make a few extra bucks. I'd bet that all these content farms would have been long banned by Google, if they weren't using adsense.
- patio11 16y agoTo be fair, I'm very happy with the performance of my ads on their pages. (For better or worse, they rank well for e.g. "How to make a bingo card" and my ads on that page have 400% ROI.) I don't think users get anything by seeing their site before my landing page, though (aside from "frustrated").
- vaksel 16y agowell you already outrank them, so maybe you are paying them to get the customers you already got. how much are you spending per click there?
- patio11 16y agoI tend to think that AdWords augments search for generic inquiries and cannibalizes it for brand queries, and I've got data kicking around somewhere here for both of those being true for BCC. (I still bid on brand queries, because I still see positive ROI on them, just not nearly as positive as AdWords thinks. Long story, ask me some day when I'm not due at a conference in 20 minutes.) I seem to have broken the Google AdWords interface and can't get exact data at the moment, but my CPC at content farms ranges from an average of 4 cents to an average of 8 cents. They send some of the highest quality traffic which is not direct from competitor's websites. (I wouldn't have predicted that but, hey, data knows more than I do.)
- RBr 16y agoI think that scum might be a little harsh. Google indexes and makes money (through adsense) on a lot worse things then content farms. However, just like a Torrent site will rarely show up on the Google's first page for a TV show name, their algorithm needs to be adjusted to account for mills that value profit over content.
- jdietrich 16y agoThe replies to this comment seem to have missed one important point: You or I might not want to eat a Chicken McNugget, but millions do. You and I might consider Demand Media-style content to be shit, but there's a market for it. We might want big, meaty content written with clever words and insightful conclusions, but the mass of the market wants little snackable boneless pieces that they don't have to work too hard to digest. Demand Media understand this. They understand that the Internet is now predominantly used by people who read at an eighth-grade level, who don't know how to use browser tabs or ctrl-f, who will go straight for the back button if presented with big blocks of text. Demand Media seek to produce huge amounts of content that is just good enough to be the most relevant content for any given long-tail search term. They do that better than anyone. Google aren't fools, they aren't being gamed, Demand Media are just creating content that is the most relevant content for very specific search terms. It's not of great quality, but it's the best that's available. If you know how to form a search query then you can find better content most of the time, but most people have neither the ability nor the inclination. Cheap, convenient, omnipresent. It's the stuff empires are made of. Like 99.99% of products in the world, it's not bad, it's just not for you. If you are strongly opposed to what other people consume, you have three proper grown-up options. Either take it up with them, satisfy that demand better, or ignore it. Railing against the people who fulfil that demand is going to get you nowhere.
- RBr 16y agoI'm going to need to revert to Mahalo as an example of content mills because it's easy for me illustrate. Demand is largely the same, just bigger and better then Mahalo. Jason Calacanis (Mahalo's CEO) describes the site as a "trifecta of search" that includes: SERP's, answers and community. He's really on to something with this. While Mahalo has taken the low road to amass low quality SERP's and recently killed the community it built, the answers building block is truly the most important part of the content mill puzzle. "We might want big, meaty content written with clever words and insightful conclusions, but the mass of the market wants little snackable boneless pieces that they don't have to work too hard to digest." No one want's big, meaty content. Everyone wants to know the answer to the question they're looking for. Sometimes, that answer can be uncovered or explained with big meaty content, but the best content will answer the question that the user is searching for with as little "meat" as possible. It's going to take content mills a while to get there, and a drastic user interface change will occur, but eventually I think that small pieces of information will exist. Similar to what happens when you type, "What time is it in Toronto" into Google, the search engine will simply return the exact answer that you're looking for. The answer might exist on Demand, it might exist on a small personal blog, however, the SE will have identified the answer to your question regardless of if you type in "How To Shave" or "Shaving Tips" or "Shaving 101".