7 ms·
A New Model for Financing Nonprofits
- clintonb 8y agoThis seems more of a method for a group of people to profit from a non-profit than it does a new method of actually financing non-profits. The non-profit is still receiving a donation. Also, the thought of investors profiting $100K from "inmate hours worked" does not sit well with me. Are the inmates being paid a decent wage?
- coffeemug 8y ago> This seems more of a method for a group of people to profit from a non-profit than it does a new method of actually financing non-profits. It is both. If the method works, this group of people won't profit from non-profits in exchange for nothing -- they'll get paid for picking non-profits that accomplish their declared goals. Suppose $X is spent on non-profit donations, and Y% of non-profits don't meet their goals. Then only $X * (1 - Y) is deployed in a meaningful way, and $X * Y is wasted -- it's the hidden cost (Hc) of today's allocation mechanism. So long as the investors get paid less than Hc, contributing $X to the donor fund instead will result in a strictly better world. I think this is promising. I would definitely consider contributing to this fund.
- lixtra 8y agoOr shorter: You donate 1$. Of that only 0.9$ go to the cause and 0.10$ is used as premium to insure that goals are met. I don’t see how the insurers have any leverage to make the non-profits meet there goals. That means that they will probably only pick non-profits with a very good reputation. But then the donors could just give 100% to the non-profit.
- walterbell 8y agoYes, it’s not clear which org is responsible for performance management of each bond, e.g. such an org requires both individual talent/expertise and institutional memory. What incentive does the nonprofit have to meet the target goals, if they get paid in all scenarios? Here is a 2016 white paper on their process for setting up a fund, https://npxadvisors.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/NPX-Whitepaper-vFINAL.pdf https://npxadvisors.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/NPX-White...
- imh 8y agoI'd guess that additional funding is harder if you don't meet goals. A lot of this seems to be pushing towards better measurements and priority alignment in the first place.
- Vinnl 8y ago> I don’t see how the insurers have any leverage to make the non-profits meet there goals. That means that they will probably only pick non-profits with a very good reputation. But then the donors could just give 100% to the non-profit. Isn't it now the investors that will make sure non-profits reach their goals? They will theoretically only invest in things that they will expect to meet their goals, so that donors actually pay them back. So donors just have to decide which non-profit's goals they want to support, and then investors help them achieve those goals. So if I understand it correctly, the primary advantage of this method should be that it helps well-performing non-profits to raise funds. And if a non-profit is high-risk but also high-value (in terms of what donors consider important to the world), they will have to donate more for investors to actually invest - but at least they'll know that they will only have to pay that if the non-profit actually achieves its goals. Of course, the challenge then is how to properly set the goals and how to objectively measure whether they're achieved.
- notahacker 8y ago> Isn't it now the investors that will make sure non-profits reach their goals? The big question then becomes why should a solely ROI-focused underwriter be better at this type of evaluation than a philanthropic foundation which (i) is actively interested in the goals (and probably also related goals/drawbacks not specified as metrics) to the extent of intending to lose money towards achieving them and (ii) likely to be a source of further funding, which means the nonprofit is more motivated both to engage with them and to actually hit the goals
- zxcmx 8y agoAs an investor, why would I invest in a non-profit with difficult-to-game metrics... Because juking the stats or a bit of weaselling in the way goals are stated is way easier and more reliable than building things or say, achieving actual health outcomes. I’m somewhat skeptical.
- Vinnl 8y agoThat is indeed a good question. That said, I don't think the underwriters should be ROI-focused - my interpretation is that current donors would be underwriters. This is a way for them to transfer the risk of what measures will result in what improvements to investors. Evaluation could be as broad as "polio should be eradicated". But yeah, there's a lot of questions left, and I don't feel like I have a good grasp on what this would entail and all its advantages either.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bradleyjg 8y agoI hope they are aware of, and have a plan to mitigate, Goodhart's law.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Shikadi 8y agoPrisoners can legally be slaves according to the 13th amendment of the Constitution. (I don't agree with it, just pointing it out)
- ensignavenger 8y agoThe 8th Amendmend to the US Constitution prohibits cruel and unusual punishment, the 13th Amendment does not nullify that. Of course it is a matter of interpretation what constitutes slavery and wether or not it is cruel or unusual punishment.
- Shikadi 8y agoPrisoners are regularly paid below minimum wage, so whether or not you or I consider it cruel or unusual, the judicial branch clearly doesn't
- qop 8y agoDo inmates deserve to make wages? They're not afforded the liberties of regular workers because they are criminals serving sentences.
- wjnc 8y agoThe concept of social impact bonds is not used often enough, but not new [1]. I first read about them about a decade ago, tried to get some politicians and civil servants engaged but alas. And then in 2017 my firm, regular profit-seeking listed insurer, suddenly participated in one... I was amazed. We give a subset of insured the option of a different treatment with regards to working while dealing with cancer (we insure the employer), a university takes care of the experiment and experimental power, other business partners deliver interventions and the banks have structered a SIB. All in motion right now. I got together with my colleague: his biggest take away: structuring a deal like this takes two to three years. He pulled it of partially because we had investments in the business partners and hence a better relation to start with. If they can make that time to market go down, the amount of possibilities are endless. Most entrepreneurs don't have the time navigating literally 4+ different tables (banks, corporations, university, government agencies) all with agendas at the same time. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_impact_bond https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_impact_bond
- walterbell 8y agoMore about Last Mile, https://thelastmile.org https://thelastmile.org ”Because of his background in venture capital, he was invited to speak to a group of men about business and entrepreneurship. He was so impressed by the men’s level of business knowledge and desire to learn, he began to nurture the idea of creating a Technology Accelerator inside the prison ... Since its inception The Last Mile has generated a groundswell of support for criminal justice across America. Never before have we experienced such a cooperative, non-partisan effort to curb the problem of mass incarceration. Imagine if we could break the cycle of incarceration and instead of spending tax dollars for prison, we could spend these tax dollars on higher education, and provide educational opportunities for youth in underserved communities.This would enable them to choose a different path than one of crime. With education and career training opportunities we could break the generational cycle of incarceration. There’s plenty of proof that the impact of one man’s incarceration is felt by families and communities for decades.”
- zachlatta 8y agoSounds like a cool idea. I run https://hackclub.com https://hackclub.com and can tell you first hand how much of a nightmare nonprofit fundraising is for early nonprofits. Talk about an inefficient market. I wonder how they're dealing with due diligence. Organizations lying about their numbers is rampant, especially in early stage. I once met with an administrator of one of the larger prison workforce development programs in SoCal and they told me that when they measured and reported program participants, they actually only measured the number of inmates that entered their program. They didn't measure completion rate, let alone long term outcomes. What does "inmate hours worked" mean? How do you prevent a race to the bottom where the org optimizes for butts in seats instead of actual outcomes?
- jpdus 8y agoThis is a good idea, but not new at all. For more details on the concept and some examples where RBF (Results based financing) is already successfully used, refer for example to Instiglio, a NGO consultancy in this space: http://www.instiglio.org/en/publications-and-resources/ http://www.instiglio.org/en/publications-and-resources/
- solatic 8y agoOne of the primary ways in which charity performance is measured today is on the percentage of money, from operating budget, spent on benefit programs, and not on administrative expenses. This allows donors to know that their money is reaching the intended beneficiaries and not administrators who are lining their own pockets in the name of the needy. Charities which adopt this model will be itemizing quick access to capital as an administrative expense being passed onto their donors, in lieu of increased benefit shown to donors who donate their money to charities not using this scheme. It seems to me like this is a solution to a problem which does not exist: if I, as a donor, want to donate my money to make a difference in the world, why do I have to choose between a proven charity with lower administrative costs and an unproven charity which is pushing its operative risk onto me, by forcing me to compensate professional investors for the risk? Why is that a difficult choice - why wouldn't I just go with the proven charity? I suppose this makes sense for you, as a donor, if you have a single issue which drives your donation decision - say, somebody close to you died of some disease or condition and you want to donate to an organization doing specific work to cure that specific disease/condition, because you are motivated by results in that specific area. So having institutional investors guarantee results will help you make the decision to donate, because you see it as a necessary cost for the specific results you're looking for. But I think most people just want to know that their money is being spent well, and for those people, percentage spent on benefit combined with reputation is a much better metric.
- chiefalchemist 8y ago> "One of the primary ways in which charity performance is measured today is on the percentage of money, from operating budget, spent on benefit programs, and not on administrative expenses." The problem is, this is flawed. It's the wrong KPI. It's the wrong carrot. For example, in order to maximize this ratio, the NPO "hires" an volunteer to design and build their website. Unfortunately, this person, while kind hearted and generous, is not very talented / experienced. Long to short, the website "loses" over $500 per week in donations. Had the NPO paid for a better site their ROI and general goodwill would be much better. Btw, the NPO does the same for their social media marketing. More "opportunity" is left on the table. Chasing the false god of mission to admin ratio __is__ one of the key mindsets that undermine plenty of NPOs.
- dalbasal 8y agoThere is a pattern, I think. Business School types look at the nonprofit sector. "Market feedback" seems to be missing. Nonprofits can be effective and efficient on the ground, but unpopular with donors. They can be popular with donors, while being ineffective on the ground. In some reductio-ad-absurdum cases, the majority of an NGO's budget is allocated to donor relations and fundraising. IEIn other words, they are trying to solve capital allocation inefficiencies. There have been several efforts at solving this, often attracting interest/support from high profile business "gurus," writers and such. For example.. GiveWell does "Cost-Effectiveness" analysis, so that willing donors can make choices on this basis. Earlier iterations "analysed" cost structure, highlighting admin/budget ratios. The Acumen Fund had/has an approach whereby many recipients are (at least partially) for profit, so that market mechanisms can come into play. Much of the "micro-credit" excitement was around this issue. Donors/Lenders would experience feedback. If a loan successfully bootstraps a business, it will be repaid. This idea seems particularly financier-oriented. It implies a lot of confidence in financial instruments' (innovative types of securities) ability to capture and deconstruct things like risk, upside, downside, volatility expected value and such. The average banker is more likely to believe it than the average person, I suspect. I'm both sympathetic and skeptical of this idea overall. I agree there is a lack of natural feedback loop, correcting and optimising capital allocation. I agree capital allocation and (moreso) incentives is a serious problem. OTOH, I'm skeptical of "financial engineering." There are always side effects to securitisation. This donor-bondholder model (being bond-based) would be risk avoiding, for example. I think that was/is a problem with micro-lending too. The "best" borrower is one who doesn't really need it, or has other options. They have the lowest default risk, but the loan probably makes a smaller difference to them. Maybe the best idea is to simply donate money to people, instead of NGOs. I think free market systems and thinking has a lot going for it, but the financial markets side of it is not really one of those things. I'm more curious about ideas that involve market feedback mechanisms which makes aid recipients consumers, rather than making donors more like investors. There is room for both, but my chips are on the consumer side, personally.
- antpls 8y ago> Maybe the best idea is to simply donate money to people, instead of NGOs. So that would be like a Basic Universal Income? I can only imagine why people give money to big NGOs, I think they want to donate money towards an ideal, for example "eradicate hunger", in a best effort way. If the money were donated directly to people, the effort would be diluted, even though it would maybe better help people. For an NGO such as The Wikipedia Foundation, to whom would you give money? Wikipedia readers? Are you suggesting we remove all the NGOs, create a worldwide found instead, and redistribute equally the donations to everyone on Earth?
- CPLX 8y agoThe finance industry essentially succeeds by jumping between two people making an exchange and skimming off as much profit as they can get away with. A giant vampire squid if you will. So of course someone has looked at the billions going to charity and tried to figure how they can get commissioned on it as well. While it's of course theoretically possible that this increases donor efficiency somehow, that's an extraordinary claim which requires evidence and proof. The initial reaction should be extreme skepticism.
- dalbasal 8y agoTo play devils advocate.. Better capital allocation could make the NGO sector way more effective, and help it actually solve issues like extreme poverty, infant nutrition and basic healthcare. Currently, one charity could be doing the same thing (say, rural inoculations in Bangladesh) 10X more effectively, but raising far less money. If a financial market can skim their 6% while solving this problem, the return in terms of the number of people inoculated could be 60% or 600%. I share your skepticism though, of solving these issues with with a new type of security. I think money markets may be the best example of free market failures.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- iamgopal 8y agoDoes software foundation counts towards nonprofits ?
- skybrian 8y agoAt first glance this seems like a silly idea. It requires raising over twice as much money, since at least half of it gets paid back to bondholders. But I think what may be happening us that it allows the donors to delay payment? The charity gets the money right away and the donors can pay later. I'm not sure the high-stakes incentives are a good idea? The donors have incentive to claim that the goals technically weren't met (even if they mostly were) while the bondholders have incentive to hide any problems. It would be interesting to know more about how the deal was designed.
- katzgrau 8y agoMy opinion is that once you tie the shorter term goals of the nonprofit to investor return on investment you've introduced a dangerous incentive for investors to exercise leverage over that nonprofit and potentially misalign its long term goals.
- dandare 8y agoThe traditional financial model has dangerous incentives on its own. Non-profits need to show more accountability.
- thelock85 8y agoThis is interesting but could generate perverse incentives. Hard-to-measure impact KPIs are a major reason why social ventures form around non- instead of for-profits (perhaps because very few individual investors see short-term economic benefit from an increase in the “greater good”). Combining $$$ ROI with philanthropic success means fewer and fewer nonprofits funded to solve hard, messy challenges.
- BerislavLopac 8y agoThere is a strong tendency to tout new, unproven methods as "revolutionary" and (shudder) disruptive. In reality, many non-profits have been continuously trying many different financing models, and those that don't work are quietly discarded and moved on. Celebrating something unproven doesn't really help -- Theranos, anyone?
- tslug 8y agoI hope this works out, but it's easy to see how it can be abused. When those abuses are addressed, the fix will undoubtedly lean on the usual fundamentals behind investing in both non-profit and for-profit ventures: due diligence on the idea and team deploying it, taking risks, hard work, and a good bit of luck.