3 ms·
Memory can be tricky. You need some data, not anecdotes.
by pnutjam 8y ago
Memory can be tricky. You need some data, not anecdotes.
- jessaustin 8y agoLots of us remember reading e.g. Shakespeare and Faulkner in high school. If the most challenging material they're reading now is Rowling (or whatever GP means by "books for children"), that is data.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Lots of us remember reading e.g. Shakespeare and Faulkner in high school. Yes, and my mom just last month retired from teachig English in a nothing-special (in ratings terms) high school in a relatively poor area, and was teaching Shakespeare, Donne, and the rest of the traditional canon of classic literature, as well as a small number of more current bits of non-juvenile literature that isn't part of the Eurocentric canon, works from Amy Tan and others (many of which I also remember reading—in college.) But in any case what makes it challenging or not isn't what books they read, but what the expectations are of what they'll be able to do having read them.
- pnutjam 8y agoYeah, lots of people "remember" doing things when they were sixteen or seventeen, or maybe even 12 or 13, but the memory gets murkier. In my experience, it's very easy for people to remember something they did at a given age fondly, and push it for their kids at a earlier age inadvertently. Memory is a tricky thing. I wouldn't be surprised if you aren't comparing today's 13 year old to your 16 year old self inadvertently.
- jessaustin 8y agoI can't believe you're really quibbling over the possibility that some high schools assign Shakespeare...