7 ms·
This article tries to make the (weak) point that there is plenty of parking simply because averages show they spots sit empty most of the time. But that type o
by jjeaff 8y ago
This article tries to make the (weak) point that there is plenty of parking simply because averages show they spots sit empty most of the time.
But that type of analysis ignores the obvious fact that most parking is built to support peak times. Most mall parking lots sit mostly empty, except on the weekends when everyone goes to the mall or restaurants or whatever. Corporate lots sit empty on the weekends.
Cut any of these lots by 25% and you cause real problems.
You could apply the same analysis to home occupancy and conclude that since most homes are sitting empty for 8 hrs a day, we could/should reduce the number of homes by 25% and be none the wiser.
- DINKDINK 8y ago>...averages show they spots sit empty most of the time. But that type of analysis ignores the obvious fact that most parking is built to support peak times. The word, that not enough technical and non-technical people know, that describes this issue is ergodicty: > an ergodic dynamical system is one that, broadly speaking, has the same behavior averaged over time as averaged over the space of all the system's states in its phase space. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ergodicity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ergodicity
- haste410 8y agoSeems like a useful term to know. Too bad the wikipedia article is too dense to understand.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoConsider editing the Wikipedia page to make the term more approachable.
- xapata 8y agoI'm not sure ergodic is what you're looking for here. Ergodic is like a gas particle in a box. Over time, it'll have been at every position in the box. Non-ergodic is like a house of cards. Eventually, it'll collapse and stay down.
- DINKDINK 8y agoLet there be a gas particle in a box. Now cut the box in half and if the gas particle can exist in all remaining space in the box, the box has had an ergodic transformation. Non ergodic: Let there be a car on a major highway in a city. Now cut the roads on the highway in half (say for construction). Congestion results and consequently the cars never again move as fast as before. (equivalent to your house of cards) def ergodic(f(),x): return f(avg(x)) == avg(f(x))
- xapata 8y agoAh, yes, traffic is non-ergodic. I thought you were suggesting the opposite. BTW, it looks like you've got a syntax error in your Python example.
- PebblesRox 8y agoEven on Black Friday many mall parking lots are far from full. https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/11/27/highlights-from-black-friday-parking-2017 https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/11/27/highlights-fr...
- ghaff 8y agoI'm not sure how much that tells you. There are plenty of moribund malls around. I'll probably be able to find plenty of parking outside JC Penney or Toys R Us at the one near me any day of the year. There are other local malls I'm not going anywhere near after about mid November.
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoYeah, malls are dying, and they're almost certainly not paying enough for the value of all that empty parking. Land value tax!
- ghaff 8y agoThe dying malls are mostly in less affluent and more rural areas where land isn't in especially high demand. That's certainly the case with the one fairly near me.
- st26 8y agoFolks on this board might be familiar with Valco, a mall which has been dying for thirty years. Smack in the middle of Cupertino, which no-one would describe as less-affluent or more-rural.
- UncleEntity 8y agoPaying who enough exactly? Dying malls get liquidated and repurposed if it's economically viable otherwise they just sit there as a giant husk of "what was" because it hurts no one for them to merely exist.
- justincormack 8y agoThe level that allows all cars to park at peak times is not the economically efficient level; that hugely increases the overall cost, as you cant use parking for any other use. Peak cases should have surge pricing to ration the space there are for efficiency, and the overall level should be less.
- crazygringo 8y agoBut they already mostly do. In far-out suburbs, huge mall parking lots aren't competing with anything else, there's plenty of space. And in downtown cities, parking garages are alreay expensive. $30-50/day in Manhattan, for example. (I would agree that street parking should match garage rates, and not be effectively subsidized, though.)
- CalRobert 8y agoThat seems pretty cheap. How much is rent on a similar amount of space? Remember all the space needed for accessing the spot, administration (if any), too! Or are there different rules for storing cars than people? (Incidentally, there very much are different rules, and for the most part US cities have worked very, very hard to make it easier to add cars than people).
- crazygringo 8y agoWell, at $5/sq ft/mo. for average real estate (Manhattan, e.g. a 600 sq ft apt is $3K/mo), and if a parking space is 180 ft, then that's $900/mo., or $30/day, plus overhead/access. So $30-50/day seems right, especially considering parking garages tend to be underground, no plumbing, etc., so the space is presumably cheaper than residential/office.
- adrianN 8y agoIf you build only one story above the parking space...
- nmoaenm342nt 8y ago
- crazygringo 8y agoExactly. I'm all for mass transit replacing cars and parking... but this article falls flat on its face trying to argue that not-enough-parking is an illusion.