2 ms·

what's democratic about states being guaranteed representation? democracy is about people having a say, not abstract entities

• DoreenMichele 8y ago
  Funny, the comment I was replying to asserts that only states get representation in the US, not people. Technically, the US is not a true democracy. Our state's speak for us and our state's represent us. This is how a presidential candidate can get less than a majority vote and still be president. There is a term for it -- maybe republic -- but I'm not that awake and can't quite put my finger on it.
  • Semirhage 8y ago
    Indirectly federated republic.
  • dannypgh 8y ago
    But, why? This transfers power to the less populous states and away from the more populous states. What's the point in doing so? The current system creates incentives for states to split in two. What's the point of that? Why is it correct that Rhode Island and Connecticut are two states, and California is one state? It strikes me as an accident of history the number of states we have. It makes sense if states have a real choice about being in the union (as otherwise the small states wouldn't go for it) but without that, what do the big states get out of it?