3 ms·
I sympathize with the EFF here to some degree... But why in the world do they think Japan cares one bit what the EFF say? Japan likes doing things their own wa
by mc32 8y ago
I sympathize with the EFF here to some degree... But why in the world do they think Japan cares one bit what the EFF say? Japan likes doing things their own way, and they will learn on their own terms what works best for them and what doesn't.
It'd be like the ACLU telling Japan how to do justice in Japan.
- walrus01 8y agoOn a global scale the EFF is quite consistent, it's not thinking Japan will care one bit. The likelihood that Japanese lawmakers read EFF position papers is pretty low. The EFF has the same position on Internet censorship whether it's Uzbekistan, Japan or Ethiopia.
- guitarbill 8y agoTo be fair to the EFF, it isn't like your ACLU example at all. Lawmakers have only been grappling with the internet and it's implications for a relatively short period (historically speaking). And there have been some bad decisions/policies. Sometimes culture plays a part, sometimes it doesn't. So it's fair for the EFF to say: "we feel this has worked for other people, and this hasn't. please take it into consideration, including chilling effects and technical pitfalls", especially for a global resource like the internet. (It's also fair for Japanese lawmakers to ignore them, which is the most likely outcome.)