3 ms·
Look, I'm sorry but this is beyond 99% of the world's IT services right now. This is of course biased, unresearched anecdata but roughly speaking - 50 % of al
by lifeisstillgood 8y ago
Look, I'm sorry but this is beyond 99% of the world's IT services right now.
This is of course biased, unresearched anecdata but roughly speaking
- 50 % of all IT installations cannot be rebuilt from scratch in an automated fashion if you have them the new hardware,plugged in.
A further ten percent could be rebuilt with mostly automated scripts and a wiki page that's out of date by two months
of the remaining 1/3 of the world's IT, 1/6 has dependencies it does not know about - the DNS server that "just works",the production routers that should not serve that subnet, the database that is "owned" by a different team whose configuration you have no control over.
Good guy d.b. has its secret passwords on the wiki page, or stored on a seperate importable module, in source control, base64-encoded
And the rest - the rest rely more on bash than ansible.
Just get the world's enterprise services over the line and into "run this python script with these parma's and you get a complete rebuild across databases and routers" and then we can talk.
- markbnj 8y agoI don't know about the numbers but you're probably speaking something close to truth here. So I'd guess the reason for the downvotes is the tone of your implication that because of this the preceding doesn't matter and is... wasting our time or something? I think it does matter. I work on a fairly small team that has to manage a lot of stuff, and we probably fall somewhere in the middle of your rough ranking. The wiki page might even be older than 2 months :). We're always looking for smarter ways to automate things (and then hoping to get the time to work on them). So to people like us things like this do matter quite a lot.
- klibertp 8y agoThat's completely beside the point. Are we supposed to shed a tear for each of that 50 %? I can do that, but it won't help me, at all. On the other hand, I can use Dhall to generate Kubernetes/Helm configs, which will be more DRY, less duplicated, and not a pain to work with. I know that this would help me quite a bit, not only because I hate my current "DevOps" team members with burning passion and I'd enjoy watching them try to figure out what is happening (well, I'd at least add the source files to a repo, that's already more than they do).
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoYou are travelling in a worldwide convoy - a convoy across the globe travelling to the future. Those 50% are not just in pointless fortune x000 companies, but governments and charities trying and failing to do useful things with their infrastructure. The convoy has wagons with broken spikes, no horses and people berating them because they are not travelling as fast as the well maintained ones in front Shed a tear for those being carried by such wagons - they could reach the future so much faster if best practises were common practises And this from someone who believes in Schumpter
- KirinDave 8y agoI still don't understand why so many of your comments here are, "People are too stupid to..." This is an excessively negative argument, and has been used many times to push back against technologies that have subsequently shown to actually have huge traction. A great example of this that the Python community still makes: lambdas are too complicated.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoThe difference here seems to be that the itch felt by the authors of this package, who are clearly skilled professionals contributing to the public good (thank you), is not likely to be an itch that 9/10 of the global IT services has time to stretch, given they have a trauma-level injury bleeding out right now. I don't think there is an OSS solution for a team that is working on five year old RHEL, differently configured servers and half the deployment is done by a different team in a different continent. This is just the default for an awful lot of the enterprise world, (no one designed it like that - it's just how internal politics got them there) and when you hit the SME world "it's been up and working for two years, we won't look too closely" I am not trying to be sarcastic or defeatist- just trying to assess reality. I am positive - this can be solved globally with really cool tools but the tools themselves do not drive their own adoption. Simple things like Docker is the thing most likely to solve most of this - yet it's enterprise adoption seems to be awfully slow (needs root? not in my data centre). But if there is a solution it is not technology - it is diktat. If every board of every company adopted one rule "You must be able to automatedly deploy a pre-prod environment that passes all automated tests, using the same scripts as the production deployment, changing only one configuration file" then world wide IT professional would leap a generation ahead.
- KirinDave 8y agoI still don't understand why you're talking about IT departments when discussing a bespoke software configuration package.