3 ms·
I'm always astounded by the pictures that are associated with black holes. Absolutely none of them are representative of what we've actually seen...because we'v
by AndrewKemendo 8y ago
I'm always astounded by the pictures that are associated with black holes. Absolutely none of them are representative of what we've actually seen...because we've never directly imaged a black hole.
I'm not even sure if we can image it, because theoretically, we're imaging the stuff around them aka the event horizon or other matter which is being acted on by the black hole.
I mention this because it's one of the best examples Along with the electron) where we have such a strong desire to create visual representation of something we can't actually perceive because our minds require visual representation to understand the concept.
- ttul 8y agoWe should have our first picture soon: https://eventhorizontelescope.org/blog/eht-status-update-may-1-2018 https://eventhorizontelescope.org/blog/eht-status-update-may...
- SiempreViernes 8y agoDon't tease me with their May update again :(
- myWindoonn 8y agoWell, slight semantic nuances of English aside, we absolutely have taken pictures of black-hole-emitted radiation; see [0] for an example. Search for photos of X-ray emissions. It's true that most of the energy seen from the direction of a black hole will be leftover scraps from its messy eating habits, but Hawking radiation should be a thing (although we'll likely never observe it above the CMBR), and rotating black holes should also be a thing. If you decide to go the fuzzball route, then perception without direct visualization isn't too hard, aside from the holographic principle, which helpfully justifies the idea that fuzzballs are a place where 3D movement becomes 2D movement. On a fuzzball, you might imagine strings moving around on the surface, but there's no meaningful way to move further into the fuzzball nor to detach from the surface and leave, aside from getting lots of energy and popping off as Hawking radiation/firewall. Incidentally, 2D movement is something that we have tons of intuition for already! [0] https://www.space.com/35231-deepest-x-ray-image-black-holes.html https://www.space.com/35231-deepest-x-ray-image-black-holes.... Edit: Many folks would consider our gravitational-wave telescopes, like LIGO, to give us data which could be interpreted visually. [1] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I_88S8DWbcU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I_88S8DWbcU
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoThis is exactly my point and the semantics do matter here because they relate to the epistemic nature of the content. Namely that humans can't directly interpret X-Rays (or other non-visible light emissions). We have to convert X-Ray emissions into images or mathematical representations which we then interpret visually/logically. So there is some level of information compression which we have to do just to be able to do some interpretation. This is not a hit on them at all, in fact it's a genius workaround. All I really want to point out here really is the limits to our perception and the lengths that we go to, in order to transform non-perceivable phenomena into into modalities that we can perceive. It's an exercise in investigating the boundaries of our epistemic capabilities.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- SiempreViernes 8y agoStrictly speaking we don't see colours at all, we just hallucinate them from the monochrome response in three (or fewer) filters. So, for example, we commonly confuse mixes of different colours with a colour between them. In this strict frame of mind, it is not a trivial epistemic statement to say that "the highlight colour at yellow.com is yellow", since your screen can not physically emit yellow light.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoYes, the rabbit hole goes deep in the perception question. Which is why I think it's important that we recognize the nested abstractions when we are trying to describe concepts - especially when they are interpreted from things that we don't have even fundamental perceptual abstractions for.
- mkagenius 8y agox-ray shouldn't be that different from the other rays of light in its behavior in illuminating an object had our eyes had evolved to detect them. So they should be same.
- dredmorbius 8y agoThe pictures we see of anything are the stuff around them. Some photo-interactive boundary conditions we are near enough, and sensitive enough, to perceive directly. Some not.
- dyukqu 8y agoHere’s what telescopes actually capture: https://www.eso.org/public/videos/eso0846j/ https://www.eso.org/public/videos/eso0846j/ (And here is a long thread about it from 4 months back if anyone is interested: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16480142 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16480142)