3 ms·
A serious problem is when people assume that because the replication crisis in psych is widely publicized that it is exclusive to psych and then they dismiss al
by UncleMeat 8y ago
A serious problem is when people assume that because the replication crisis in psych is widely publicized that it is exclusive to psych and then they dismiss all of the findings in the field. In my experience the replication crisis is rarely used to criticize method but instead used to dismiss research out of hand, whether or not it is supported by other research that limits the likelihood of error.
I think that psych should be commended for attacking this problem. As a field they are funding replications, which basically never happens in any other field. We don't even know what the "replication crisis" would be in empirical CS. Given discussions with ML people I'd wager that the "replication crisis" in ML is at least as dramatic.
Science is messy. But this is why we should defer to experts who have vision over an entire field rather than focusing on individual papers as conclusive data points.