4 ms·
>Isn't the larger issue that the DNC, Podesta, and Clinton did and said things that weren't aligned with their public statements? No, the larger issue would st
by krapp 8y ago
>Isn't the larger issue that the DNC, Podesta, and Clinton did and said things that weren't aligned with their public statements?
No, the larger issue would still be a foreign power attempting to influence an American election by illegal means. That doesn't actually stop becoming illegal or an issue of national security because one doesn't like the party being targeted.
- hanshan 8y agoOne could indict every major world power for foreign election interference. Laws are meaningless if no one follows them.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- krapp 8y ago>One could indict every major world power for foreign election interference And yet the rest of the world still complains when America does it. If it's a problem when America does it, it's a problem when Russia does it. >Laws are meaningless if no one follows them. Laws are also meaningless if no one enforces them.
- wu-ikkyu 8y ago>>Laws are meaningless if no one follows them. >Laws are also meaningless if no one enforces them. And still, Rule of Law requires that those who enforce the law, follow the law.
- krapp 8y ago>And still, Rule of Law requires that those who enforce the law, follow the law. Countries that believe the US interferes with their elections are free to try to do what the US is doing, and attempt to prosecute a case against whomever they can catch. Otherwise... what conclusion are we meant to reach? That countries which engage in espionage or which interfere with other countries' elections shouldn't have espionage laws or should allow any interference in their own? There's no argument of equivocation one could make to excuse or exonerate Russia in this case that doesn't also do the same for the US.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>Laws are meaningless if no one follows them. The truth to that statement has to do with power and influence. The average Joe isn't gonna get out of a speeding ticket by saying everyone speeds.
- SlowRobotAhead 8y agoRight... That's something the USA does all over the world.
- mbesto 8y agoI could be wrong, but "Hacking an election" is not by definition illegal per say. However, accessing a computer illegally or defrauding people with the intention to meddle in an election is indeed illegal. If <insert country here> had an election and the US-CIA had hackers put malicious code in their voting machines, and that country had laws against tampering with voting machines, then I would fully expect that country to indict those involved. Obviously in a geopolitical environment, that usually means through sanctions or some other means.
- yongjik 8y agoIf US embassy in Korea did anything similar to influence Korean election, and if it was found out, you can be assured that people will throw some major shit and there will be protests, both on the streets and in the national assembly, and heads will start rolling. America understands this, and does not try to influence Korean election (or, if they still do, they are really careful not to get caught), because the risk of it backfiring is simply too much. ...And South Korea was basically America's puppet state during the majority of its existence.
- thucydidesofusa 8y agoI'm going to do my best to have a good faith argument. I agree with the assertion that the US elections should be free from foreign influence, however, Russia is accused of simply bringing unfavorable things to light, it doesn't seem like they invented/constructed anything, they just amplified prexisting tensions - they're accused of organizing anti-Trump rallies and espousing pro-BLM views, certainly that's unacceptable influencing but it's not a dynamic because of the Russians. But the Russians weren't the only ones who did this, the President of Mexico was firmly against Trump and I recognize that as an unacceptable foreign influence. How do you recognize the difference between acceptable and unacceptable foreign influence and was the President of Mexico acting in a way that was acceptable?
- merpnderp 8y agoIt is mind boggling to me that people are shocked at this. It has been going on for decades, going back to at least the time the USSR tried to help Kennedy win the election. What happened was expected at every election, it's on the DNC and FBI for not protecting their servers. Never mind the joke being on the Russians as Trump is turning out to be several times tougher on them than Hillary would likely have been, even going so far as to start threatening their European gas pipelines.
- krapp 8y ago>Never mind the joke being on the Russians as Trump is turning out to be several times tougher on them than Hillary would likely have been, even going so far as to start threatening their European gas pipelines. That's odd. During the campaign, I distinctly remember Hillary being described as an insane bloodthirsty war hawk who was going to plunge us into World War 3 against Russia at the first opportunity, and Trump as the reasonable man who understood Russia and just wanted to do business.
- polotics 8y agoTrump is destroying the alliance, starting trade wars, and squandering any moral advantage western democracies may have in eastern discourse with his many behavior failings. If that's tough on Russia you have to explain how.