3 ms·
At its inception, the EC was a parliament solely elected to pick the president; as a result, not all the electors in a state elected the same person. This start
by bobthepanda 8y ago
At its inception, the EC was a parliament solely elected to pick the president; as a result, not all the electors in a state elected the same person. This started changing in the 1800s; states that wanted to increase campaign time in their state moved toward the winner-takes-all method, which then every state had to move to if they wanted to matter equally.
If EC votes in a state were allocated according to popular vote, then the existing system would be a lot fairer. Proportional EC essentially reduces the advantage of campaigning in swing states, since many more states become swing states due to the relative ease of swinging a single EV vs. a whole state. And it manages to do so without completely screwing over smaller states.
I did some napkin math a while ago for this, but if this was the case, Bush v Gore would've been decisively for Gore, Bush v Kerry would have been as close as OTL Bush v Gore, and Trump's margin of victory shrinks to about 20 electoral votes from 77.
- mrgriscom 8y agoI explored the same thing but got different results from you. Bush v. Gore almost a dead tie and 2016 a slight Hillary win. http://mrgris.com/blog/2016-12-06-538-problems-but-a-swing-state-aint-one/ http://mrgris.com/blog/2016-12-06-538-problems-but-a-swing-s...
- bobthepanda 8y ago"Back of the napkin" was quite literal. Staring at tables on the internet makes you go blind if you do it hard enough.