3 ms·
Sometimes I think I’m the only person on HN who strongly prefers a detached, single family house with plenty of space between neighbors. I’ve done apartment liv
by ryandrake 8y ago
Sometimes I think I’m the only person on HN who strongly prefers a detached, single family house with plenty of space between neighbors. I’ve done apartment living and condo living and will never voluntarily return to it. Some benefits of owning a single family detached home:
1. I have a small kid with a lot of running energy who plays in the yard every day. Having to walk to the nearest park (if one exists) is inconvenient especially if it’s miles away.
2. I’m done with loud neighbors. Constant parties, loud bass music rattling the shared walls, loud sex at all hours, loud conversations right outside my door. It was a constant attribute of dense urban living.
3. Hobbies that require lots of private space and machinery, like sheet metal working and carpentry. Not going to be possible in a townhome without being yourself the annoying loud neighbor.
4. Freedom to customize. If I want to mount a huge antenna on my roof or build a backyard shed, only a detached home allows this.
5. Related to 4: Authority to fix things when they break. If my roof is leaking I can choose if and when to fix it. I can shop around for contractors to make sure I’m not overpaying. I can inspect and approve the work. In an apartment or condo these important tasks are out of my hands and done (always poorly) by an incompetent committee or landlord.
6. (For car owners) Indoor car parking and protection from the elements measurably reduces the maintenance cost of those cars. And fixing cars is tons easier in a garage. Nothing worse than replacing your power steering system in a 2 by 4 meter parking space surrounded by your neighbors’ cars. Ask me how I know.
- zzzzzzzza 8y ago4 -> local hackerspace (but like 1 whether or not city has this depends on your location) 5. You could buy a condo and then be responsible for repairs if you so wished (though this adds another point, sometimes you'll have to deal with e.g. upstairs neighbors toilet leaking) 6. Of course one of the biggest appeals of urban living for many would be not having to own a car
- lmm 8y agoIt comes down to: do I get more value out of space with other people in or space without them? Would I rather my kid have lots of space to play by themselves, or lots of other kids to play with (but only one park between them all)? Would I rather have space for my own carpentry shop, or enough neighbours that there will be a few carpenters among them (but only one workshop between us)? Would I rather have car parking spaces or cafes and theatres? I think more people around me is a net positive overall, though there are definitely exceptions.
- jcims 8y agoAt this point I'm thinking I need two homes that I can swap between every couple of years. I'm currently living in a nicely secluded property in the corner of a rural county in Ohio. It's like a living sanctuary and I'm addicted to being here. However, my kids haven't proven to be inclined to make use of the particular advantages it provides, and time is a-wastin'. So now we're thinking about moving into an urban area to give them more opportunity to engage with others. The problem is that I've lived like that before as well and it makes me nearly homicidal after a very short while. It's clearly a personal flaw, but I don't know how to fix it. I could be surrounded by 99% awesome people, but it just takes that special mongrel to spoil it all. Maybe I've matured enough in the past few years to handle it better, but it sure would be nice to have the option to bail if we choose poorly.
- danans 8y agoYour examples contrast the two extremes of housing density: detached home surrounded by lots of land vs high density apartments. There is a huge swath of possibilities in between, including dense, detached housing, smaller condo developments, and villages that provide many of the benefits you attribute only to detached low density housing, including self maintenance, private parking, etc. With higher density, these places also provide easy access to greenspace for children, with the qualification that it is usually public greenspace. You are not as likely to find this setup in big city centers like Manhattan or Chicago, nor in the vast low density suburban sprawl, but rather in older pre-car towns that have retained their human scale development pattern.
- greggman 8y agoI want it because that's what I grew up with. I loved everything about it. We had a 3 bedroom house with living room and kitchen and 2 car garage. In the garage my dad had a workbench with a bunch of tools and a radial saw. He added on a 20x30ft family room which he mostly built. He built it to be somewhat sound proof because he played drums, bass, and guitar semi professionally. Because it was opposite side of the house from his bedroom and because it was semi-soundproof my sister and I could have slumber parties with 4-8 friends over and be as loud as we wanted. Why wouldn't I want that again? I loved being able to be loud. To watch an action movie at 2am . My dad's stereo had 8 sets of speakers floor to ceiling. Him and my mom would host an 80 person New Years Eve party every other year. Ever since I moved out 30 yrs ago I've lived in nothing but apartments where I mostly have to tiptoe to not annoy the neighbors. Can't have a dog. Can't have a workbench with tools. Can't have more than 2-4 guests over at once. Have to watch TV with headphones on if I want any volume. I get the desire to live downtown near other things but I also get the desire to own a single family detached house. They're awesome!