11 ms·
People absolutely want large detached houses, but housing developers want to build densely packed multi-family housing because they're more profitable. Here's
by Spivak 8y ago
People absolutely want large detached houses, but housing developers want to build densely packed multi-family housing because they're more profitable.
Here's the problem:
- Start with a nice, quiet, picturesque suburban neighborhood.
- Naturally people want to move into this neighborhood because it's so nice and want it to be affordable so, absent zoning, developers build apartments and condos to fill the need.
- Then all the people move in and the neighborhood slowly learns that the reason it was actually nice and picturesque was the low density and high buy-in.
- Property values start going down, along with tax revenue, the schools decline, $/student plummets, and all the people with the means move somewhere else.
Without at least some laws it's incredibly difficult to break this cycle.
- Retric 8y agoYou have it backwards, increased density results in higher prices. However, there are multiple cycles going on. If you build a development you end up with a lot of people of similar means all buying homes. But, over time things change as people get fired / retire / inherent homes etc you revert to the mean over time. On top of that as homes age and become less desirable you get massive downward pressure on property values over time. In the other direction you have artificial scarcity and sometimes increasing population propping up home values.
- Retric 8y agoPS: To thous who disagree, I will point out Manhattan as a classic case of high density and high cost. Feel free to pick some real counter examples.
- rcpt 8y agoIt's expensive in Manhattan but it's affordable nearby. It's still possible to buy an apartment in Jackson Heights for $200k and take the F train to work. In the Bay Area it's expensive near job centers but it's still expensive 40 miles away. The sprawling mess is too low density to sensibly cover with trains so poor people end up with insane highway commutes.
- Retric 8y agoThat's still expensive. Anacostia DC has apartments for 90k despite people paying 4+x as much to commute into DC from the suburbs. However, those prices are very much on the rise. SV prices are limited largely by geography and local parks. Having less land area available for development relative to commute distances drives up prices on top of other issues.
- rcpt 8y agoI don't understand your point here. It sounds like you are saying that Anacostia is cheap, dense, and close to jobs and that there's also a demand for luxury housing farther away. That all sounds reasonable to me. In SV we don't have cheap housing close to jobs. I argue this is because we don't have dense housing.
- Retric 8y agoMy point was markets are complex and 200k is not cheap. Anacostia is an example of less expensive, but also not cheap. You can get a 'cheap' condo in much of the US for 35k. However, Anacostia is not staying that way prices are very much on the rise, became larger forces are at work. SV does not have cheap housing close to jobs largely due to geographic issues. It has a tiny strip of land that can be developed so all of it is going to be expensive. On a block by block basis low density is driving prices down, while on a regional basis lack of housing anywhere drives prices up.
- rcpt 8y agoI'm still not following you here. Sure, housing is cheap in and around Detroit or wherever but you explicitly requested we discuss Manhattan. Now, in Manhattan the city center is expensive. However, very near the city center, housing can be affordable while still having a reasonable commute. This is because of density. > SV does not have cheap housing close to jobs largely due to geographic issues. It has a tiny strip of land that can be developed so all of it is going to be expensive. You are totally wrong here. The housing is expensive due to undersupply which is brought about by restrictions on zoning. There is a huge amount of land to build on but zoning laws require that most of the land here be used for detached single family homes.
- Spivak 8y agoManhattan is high density and high cost but that's because the desire to live there is nigh-infinite. The prices aren't high because it's dense, they're high despite. You're essentially arguing that housing is a Giffin Good and exists outside the normal laws of supply and demand. Don't get me wrong, after a point there is a tipping point where more people start pushing prices up in general because they exhaust the supply of things you can't just produce more of. But building more housing still decreases the price of housing.
- Retric 8y agoHousing is not interchangeable like a true commodity. Sure, over the next six months prices may drop but consider longer term. Take an island city of say 1 million people living in single family homes. Now, over 50 years replace 1/2 of those with 5 million high density apartments. Assuming steady growth the apartments are going to fill with workers, but the number of single family homes dropped. Further, the total number of highly paid professionals like Doctors and Middle Management increases which increases demand for those single family homes. Now, block growth for 30 years and you reduce the number of people that can actually make enough money to drive up prices. Net result people move elsewhere and even if the market is tight and people pay a higher percentage of their income they simply make less money on average. PS: And to be pedantic while more housing is being build to total supply drops because nobody is living in the demolished buildings.
- emodendroket 8y agoManhattan also has one of the world's largest concentrations of jobs and various cultural things to attract people. You will not see the same effect at work if you are comparing suburban apartment complexes to suburban single-family homes.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> People absolutely want large detached houses, but housing developers want to build densely packed multi-family housing because they're more profitable. They also cost less per unit, which is a thing people (i.e. new homeowners) like even more. > - Property values start going down, along with tax revenue, the schools decline, $/student plummets, and all the people with the means move somewhere else. This can be solved by adjusting the mil rate to generate the original amount of property tax revenue per unit against the lower housing prices. I also don't see how the cycle is not self-defeating. If there are a hundred low density units and someone builds a hundred high density units near them so the original inhabitants leave and build a hundred new low density units somewhere else, now there are three hundred housing units available. The higher supply reduces the profit in building new condos anywhere in the region. If the cycle repeats then even more housing is constructed. At some point the profit in building new condos falls below the construction cost, because people don't want to live in a condo in the otherwise low density area more than they want to have a much smaller mortgage payment.
- emodendroket 8y agoIn this scenario a lot of people probably still have to commute to the city or nearby so moving to further and further rings out has real disadvantages
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> In this scenario a lot of people probably still have to commute to the city or nearby so moving to further and further rings out has real disadvantages This is obviously an argument in favor of high density zoning. Even if you want to live in a detached single family home, you want as many other people as possible to be able to live in high density housing to minimize the amount of land you have to drive through between your home and the city.
- emodendroket 8y agoPerhaps, but you can see how this is not necessarily a situation where what's good for the goose is good for the gander.
- gascan 8y agoPeople absolutely want large detached houses, but housing developers want to build densely packed multi-family housing because they're more profitable. To me it has always seemed that presented a big empty plot of land, large detached houses are more profitable for the builder- I figure single houses are probably easier to slap together. Then, as an area grows and land is suddenly constrained in supply, then the developer wants to build dense.
- Spivak 8y agoYou're right, single family houses are very nice for the builder. Simple, relatively cheap, build-sell-and-move-on. Multi-family houses are more profitable for the owner. You pay some maintenance costs but you also collect a profit on recurring condo fees, services you provide, and deals you might make with other companies (like internet providers).
- jellicle 8y ago> Then all the people move in > Property values start going down So you're saying that because it's so desirable, property values go down?
- Spivak 8y agoTwo ways to answer this: * Yes, the existence of less expensive high-density housing in a neighborhood puts downward pressure on the price of single-family homes. * Yes, because the value of an affluent, quiet, low-density neighborhood is just that -- exclusivity.
- jellicle 8y agoAre there any instances of this happening, ever? > Yes, the existence of less expensive high-density housing in a neighborhood puts downward pressure on the price of single-family homes. That's false. If land can be redeveloped into high density housing, developers will pay top dollar for it. An 80-story tower going up next to your bungalow may seem annoying to you, but some developer is going to pay you a mountain of money for that bungalow - way more than you could get for it from a regular purchaser - knock it down, and build their own 90-story tower.
- nine_k 8y agoInterestingly, metro areas with high to very high density, like Seattle or Austin or New York, are pretty popular recently, in many regards because of the density and walkability. But likely they attract a different kind of people than those who want quiet and picturesque low-density suburbia.
- emodendroket 8y agoYeah, I don't think you're going to find a lot of people who are considering both options.