5 ms·
I admit I only skimmed the article, but I still throw in a potential controversal counterthought (even though I don't disagree with the article from what I read
by hutzlibu 8y ago
I admit I only skimmed the article, but I still throw in a potential controversal counterthought (even though I don't disagree with the article from what I read):
People* are dumb.
Why?
They have been breed like that for many generations. Because all the classic Civilisations and Empires needed lots of dumb workers and peasants who were able to do their simple work, but not smart enough, to organize any opposition against the current empire.
And this in many different forms, from total slavery to all kinds in between.
Now with the Hypothesis, that smart people don't want to get exploited, they would rise up sometimes, where they grew in numbers - and got beaten down and crucified, hanged, quartered, etc. - so strong selection pressure for smart people not born into the elite and not wanting to become a monk.
Now with all that being said, I believe it is probably more a cultural mindset of "stupidness" than "stupid" DNA in the people, because smart people also keep their heads low and pretend to be stupid, when they can't win a fight. But this got into a habit of not wanting to think.
So the solution to all the complex problems in the world I don't think is a super government, thinking for all their dumb sheeps, but rather smaller systems, less complex - and letting people get smart again, by giving them the opportunity to make decisions again about their life. Not just a allmost meaningless vote which allmost counts nothing among the millions of other votes, but voting the decisions down at their very local lifes. When you have to think for yourself, you will start thinking again.
And then you don't want those decisions taken away from you. Thats only comfortable when you forgot how to do it.
* with "people" I mean the average person in the street, the one from the famous Churchill quote
- ppeetteerr 8y ago>* with "people" I mean the average person in the street, the one from the famous Churchill quote Most people are dumb about most things, good at a small number of things, and excel in one to three things.
- taeric 8y agoOddly, I think if you were to take that in a slightly different direction, you'd get more traction. Specifically, take your * and have it say * by "people" I mean collections of people. Individuals often show remarkable intelligence. Even that, of course, ignores that there is some wisdom in crowds. I'd guess there is a sense of "inertia" in how people behave/think. With more people, more inertia. Slower changes and seemingly slower progress sometimes.
- hutzlibu 8y agoYou got me wrong. I never said that groups in general are stupid. I meant specifically a average group of average people today. And stupid in the sense that they fail to see any big picture(and also the picture in front of their eyes is usually quite blurry). Quite problematic in a globalised world.
- taeric 8y agoApologies, I meant that I am more open to the other interpretation. My hypothesis being that I am like most people. :) (Obvious flaws in said hypothesis.) I don't necessarily think either interpretation is correct. I am curious on just how correct either are. That is, I suspect this is purely a probabilities thing. If that makes sense.
- jimbofisher1 8y agoI think its extremely unlikely that there is any actual evolutionary process selecting for less intelligent people, in fact the opposite is probably more likely to be true. I'm not sure you were really sugesting that though.
- hutzlibu 8y agoThere is different kinds of intelligence. Like said, it can be smart to not be smart, if you want to survive under a stupid, but powerful regime. Smart in that moment, not so smart now, when it is wise, to understand more, than just be able.to follow simple orders. Robots can do that better.
- jimbofisher1 8y agoHow does that play out today because it is very lucrative to be smart in today's world. You don't get to work at FAANG or on Wall Street by pretending to be less intelligent than you are. The same applies across many industries like Academia, Healthcare, Law etc. You may have to suppress opinions that go against the grain of the industry you are in but I don't see that as being the same.
- hutzlibu 8y agoYes, you have to be very smart today.
- gilbetron 8y agoThat seems like an incredibly uneducated view of what the world was like previously.
- hutzlibu 8y agoInteresting, care to provide arguments? I provided mine: we had empires as default, they needed lots of slaves. Slaves must be strong, but stupid. Smart slaves were trouble. So got sorted out. Simplified, yes, but "uneducated" where?
- gilbetron 8y ago> Interesting, care to provide arguments? Read a history book. Hell, read Timeline by Michael Crichton.
- hutzlibu 8y agoNot an argument. I believe I read a lot of history books. So can you then provide me with your enlightened wisdom that you got, I apparently failed to grasp?
- gilbetron 8y ago"needed lots of dumb workers and peasants who were able to do their simple work" Sounds like a very Monty Python-esque view of history, that's all. Perhaps you have a far more nuanced view, but it doesn't come across as such.
- crpatino 8y agoYou are wrong in every account. No preindustrial civilization would have survived with a work force of dumb workers. They'd have all starved to death or, more likely, get conquered by smarter neighbours. Even 100 years ago, the relatively unskilled workers needed extensive amounts of specialized knowledge to complete their simple tasks efficiently. Second, it is factually impossible for political elites to breed their populations in any significant way. While there have been some Great Cultures with a lifespan of millenia, most dinasties last no more than a handful of generations (the Romanovs of Russia being one of the longest runners at 300 years). Furthermore, there's the issue of social movility. Between the tendency of elite males to intercourse with their female subjects, the whole elite family falling in disgrace with their peers, etc; whatever genetic advantage the rulers do have at any time is guaranteed to reach the hoi-poloi sooner rather than later. And let's not forget the fact that there are always pockets of challengers to the current authority from within the "proletariat", edging any niche of influence available to better their lot in life; which puts them in a position to overthrow the current elite whenever those happen to loose their grasp of the political realities of the land (which, judging from history books, only takes one or two generations detachment from intense troubles).
- tootie 8y ago"Because all the classic Civilisations and Empires needed lots of dumb workers and peasants who were able to do their simple work, but not smart enough, to organize any opposition against the current empire." I think that's a pretty preposterous claim. Selective breeding of humans has happened in earnest very rarely in human history. Far too little to have created an evolutionary bottleneck. The Flynn Effect would seem to indicate that the opposite has been happening at least in recent history. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect