3 ms·
I didn't read Guns Germs and Steels like that. I read it as portraying an alternative explanation to the "genetic superiority" explanation. It seemed quite plau
by Tichy 19y ago
I didn't read Guns Germs and Steels like that. I read it as portraying an alternative explanation to the "genetic superiority" explanation. It seemed quite plausible to me, but I am not sure if it is true. It was good enough for me to prove that "genetic superiority" is not the only possible solution - a lot of people don't seem to think so, so I think the book is important.
I will read "The Blank Slate" - I have been meaning to read another one of Pinker's books for ages.
Obviously, there are genetic differences between people. Their effect is another question. Also, the environment is involved in computing the phenotype from the gene. So one and the same gene could produce stupid people in one environment, and in another one smart people (as an example).
I haven't read the book yet, but perhaps you can provide some really compelling evidence for genes (of a "race") making a difference. True, pygmies probably won't make great basketballers, but that is not the kind of example we are looking for, or is it?
Typically sports is being mentioned in that context, but I don't think it is a very compelling example (safe for the pygmies example). It might just as well be percentages of people choosing to take up sports, for whatever reasons (like maybe, because it offers them the best opportunities).
- aswanson 19y agoEDIT -- In reference to The Blank Slate: I read it awhile back, and while there are some stretches in his usage of evolution to explain every form of behavior, e.g., people sat around fires for millenia therefore storytelling ability evolved, his explanations concerning adaptations for general survival utility are well supported. I would recommend reading it with a grain of salt, and take evolutionary psychology for what it is, with the same level of skepticism you would apply to get data from any social "science". EDIT--Some suggestive guideposts when reading in this field: http://www.gnxp.com/MT2/archives/003817.html http://www.gnxp.com/MT2/archives/003817.html http://itb.biologie.hu-berlin.de/~hagen/papers/Controversies.pdf http://itb.biologie.hu-berlin.de/~hagen/papers/Controversies... http://www.badscience.net/?p=518 http://www.badscience.net/?p=518 Be on the lookout for handwaving, but certainly investigate. Don't make it the only book you read in this area...
- Tichy 19y ago"people sat around fires for millenia therefore storytelling ability evolved" I've read "How the Mind Works" before and really liked it, so I have good expectations of Pinker. But in general, that kind of use of evolution theory is really tiresome. No matter what you want to "prove", you can always make up a story and then tag it with "therefore xyz evolved".