4 ms·
It also means laws/regulations to just plain ban harmful behaviors. Collectivization to alter market forces cannot fix everything. Some things need to just st
by sandworm101 8y ago
It also means laws/regulations to just plain ban harmful behaviors. Collectivization to alter market forces cannot fix everything. Some things need to just stop. Selling CFCs needs to stop. That won't happen by naming and shaming involved companies. It won't happen by people gathering on facebook to organize a boycott. It happens by people in uniforms enforcing the law, with violence when necessary. Sometimes that is the only way to stop individuals bent on illegally benefiting
themselves at the expense of others.
- mhb 8y agoWell it takes collective action to decide what to ban.
- sandworm101 8y ago>> collective action to decide No. Once upon a time we nominated experts to make most of those decisions. Groups like the EPA or the IRS were given a mandate to examine what was going on and ban behaviors that did harm. But today "regulation" is a bad word. Everything is political. The EPA and IRS cannot ban anything without massive public debate. In fact, most regulatory bodies are so under pressure to reduce any and all regulation that they rarely ever ban anything. Quick and efficient regulation of harmful behavior is dead. Example: the recent bill to ban upskirting photography in the UK. Nothing much to debate. But the bill gets killed by the new breed of politicians who demand every new regulation be subject to the full public process in order to make the act of passing new regulations as difficult as possible.
- aalleavitch 8y agoWhat we lack is trust. We lack security in each other, in many cases for entirely legitimate reasons. Reestablishing systems of trust is one of the challenges we’re facing right now.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoIn general I probably agree with you. But I seriously can not comprehend how that applies to the example given in the parent post.
- smolder 8y agoI'll take a stab. People don't trust their government or their justice system to fairly enforce the law or to draft a law that, all legalese deconstructed, is fair in the first place.
- Nasrudith 8y agoReminds me of the one common Freudian slip I notice in the wake of a scandal. If they talk of restoring trust as a goal they are so irredeemably corrupt they see only the bad PR as a problem and not the heinous abuses. Since trying to fix the problem doesn't even come to mind to them as something to lie about when they are in hot water!
- bluGill 8y agoOn your example: are you sure there is nothing to debate? No possible harm? No possible unintended consequence? One thing I've observed over and over is that there are unintended consequences to everything. It often takes years to figure them out.
- User23 8y agoThank you for this lucid description of the authoritarian position.
- Nursie 8y agoIn the case of individual or small group actions that have the capability to seriously fuck things up for everyone else, what other position is rational?
- fucking_tragedy 8y agoViewing regulation as authoritarianism is an extremist position.
- User23 8y agoWhy was this flagged? Men using violence to enforce a preferred policy is exactly authoritarian. A simple factual description is in no way pejorative.
- dang 8y agoWould you please not post ideological battle comments to HN? They're not what this site is for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- bilbo0s 8y ago"...Sometimes that is the only way to stop individuals bent on illegally benefiting themselves at the expense of others...." Not just "sometimes", it takes the threat of violent people in uniforms ALL of the time when dealing with people bent on illegally benefiting themselves at the expense of others. The issue is that the violent people in uniforms, (and even the people controlling them for that matter), can ALSO be bent on benefiting themselves at the expense of others. It's not only grassroots organizations that can be corrupt, the government itself is actually even more likely to be corrupt. So you almost have to solve corruption before you try to solve the other structural issues. And corruption is just a very hard problem to solve.
- mhneu 8y agoCory Doctorow has recently written an interesting piece on corruption: https://boingboing.net/2018/07/02/low-yield-crude.html https://boingboing.net/2018/07/02/low-yield-crude.html It talks about how socializing risk and privatizing profits is actually the definition of corruption.