5 ms·
Disagree. Just be real. When I joined my current company, they had a project kicking off with a ridiculously short timeline. I asked the product manager to thin
by tootie 8y ago
Disagree. Just be real. When I joined my current company, they had a project kicking off with a ridiculously short timeline. I asked the product manager to think about how many stories were in the backlog, how many might be added as we went, how many stories they could get through per sprint given the team capacity and then you can put a rough date on it and continue adjusting every sprint as the backlog shrinks and you get a clear picture of velocity. Our first pass put us about 400% over the allotted time (an estimate that has held up pretty well since then).
Next step, is to spell this out to your project team leadership completely unvarnished. Tell them your conclusion and how you got there. Don't let them bargain over your reasoning unless they actually have better evidence. The key is to never say "this is too hard" or "we don't have enough people" or make any other excuses. Not should you be overly emotional. Just give the facts. It's a fait accompli.
Then just ask how they want to deal with it. There is absolutely nothing to be gained from beating around the bush. I've done this more than once and was always taken seriously. One time we had even already signed a fixed-bid contract before I was able to give them an estimate. What you've committed too doesn't change the course of what's actually going to happen.
- scardine 8y agoThis is how things should run if the work culture was logic based but with rare exceptions it isn't. As a borderline autistic person I have a very direct communication style and lost account of how many times I burned myself for failing to "beat around the bush". You can't say "the project is doomed" even if it is true. You can't say it will be so over budget and take so long that it would be better to cut the losses now. Don't expect to go unpunished for saying "the king is nude". According to my experience both parents are absolutely right, but the first is how most organizations work and the second is an ideal seldom found in the real world.
- scardine 8y agoPS: you do get some leeway when you just joined a company, enjoy your honeymoon grace period.
- _vn5r 8y agoDepends on the circumstances you joined the company. In some, you actually have to "earn your place" in the company, and most recommendations I've seen are "keep quiet and listen".
- newbie912 8y agoAbsolutely. I'm about 3 months in at a new company and starting to see areas for improvement. I just make a note and keep my mouth shut. In another 3-6 months I'll have earned the right to start diplomatically suggesting some of my ideas. For now i just try to understand the thinking that went into decisions that resulted in our current state. If you want to go into a new organization and "be disruptive" and you're not a management consultant, be prepared for the likely outcome of failure.
- lostcolony 8y agoNope. It will tar you forever amongst anyone you say it to as someone with a bad attitude, divisive, etc. I spent three years at a company where a VP basically viewed me dimly (if, admittedly, necessary) because I delivered bad news early on. It was polite and reasonable, but he was in a difficult place, had people actively whispering "Everything is fine" in his ear, and so when it eventually did blow up (and I was one of the ones who swooped in to fix everything ASAP), it was less "I should have listened" and more "(I) just added to (his) pain".
- tootie 8y agoAttitude is important. Like I said, deliver this news as though it's inescapable objective reality. Akin to saying we can't have a picnic because it's raining. It's nobody's fault and it's not due to anyone's shortcomings. Estimating is hard, building good software takes time. This is how much time this project will take. Let us know evaluate the impact and decide how to cope. It doesn't need to be an argument.
- lostcolony 8y ago
- hashkb 8y agoBeing real can be a massive mistake when management is more concerned with preserving management than revenue. It's pretty common, and experienced managers are way better at getting you out than at fixing problems. (Well, they see it as one and the same)
- jobu 8y ago> Just be real. This works pretty well in smaller companies or startups, but corporate culture is usually political enough that it would be a disaster for your career. > Then just ask how they want to deal with it. Disagree. Anytime you find a problem you should come up with at least two solutions before you bring it to leadership. Managers hate people that only come to them with problems. You're closest to the project and you should be the one to know the situation and possible solutions.
- vannevar 8y agoAnytime you find a problem you should come up with at least two solutions before you bring it to leadership. Yes. I think many people who believe they were punished for delivering bad news were actually punished for not offering ways to solve the problem. It's easy to simply say, "the project is doomed" and leave the problem in management's lap; much harder to come up with creative ways to rescue a bad situation.
- lostcolony 8y agoOh, hey. You had a fully fleshed out backlog, some initial tracking, with a PO who actually wanted to know rather than just tell the business "everything is okay" and block his ears (knowing that failure to deliver will reflect dev, not him). You had leaders who were willing to listen to facts rather than prioritize consensus (which brings with it the belief that because you were the dissenting voice in the room demonstrates you're divisive and a problem). You landed in a really good culture, just one that hadn't faced reality yet. You've yet to plumb the depths of corporate America. :P
- badloginagain 8y ago> You landed in a really good culture Here's the crux of the matter. Your approach needs to be tailored to the culture you're in. The higher up in the leadership chain you go, the more important your understanding of the political machinations of your company is. All corporations have politics, even the smallest startups. Some are just more cutthroat/feudal/kafkaesque than others.
- borkt 8y agoOnce you realize you are at a company where telling the truth leads to a negative consequence (an incompetent manager hired after the truth told. Their first time managing a department. The department did not previously exist in the enterprise. The department is specifically to roll out a technology they have never worked with before throughout a large company. Lets say you were in charge of the project, are intimately familiar with the technology, and had a clear plan that would lead to success but upper management wasn't happy with the timeline. Their goal seems to be to quickly complete this project to display it as a "win". Now the new manager was brought in, does not understand or care to understand the complexity of the project, and just keeps asking "when will it be done". Then got tired of that and changed to have it done in 2 weeks which is unreasonable, and then gave you an entirely false, negative performance review based on information they apparently forgot to actually verify or they would have known it was already complete and the people who were on the receiving end of the product are incredibly happy. HR is asking for a meeting to discuss, what do you do? Tell HR about the depth of the incompetence Tell HR you weren't getting support from upper management Tell HR to look into what on earth was the reason this specific manager was selected. or GTFO? This is a real life circumstance I am dealing with. I believe in the technology but unless changes are made it will be a guaranteed failure. Upper management likes the technology and really wants success here, but I know it wont happen unless then changes are made, and the people between the senior executives and me are making it impossible to be a success.
- graedus 8y ago> One time we had even already signed a fixed-bid contract before I was able to give them an estimate. Only one time?? Are you hiring? :)